1
00:00:02,671 --> 00:00:06,451
John: On episode thirty one of Out of
Play Area, the game developers podcast,

2
00:00:06,451 --> 00:00:13,656
we sit down with Ben Retan a lead AI and
encounter designer at Hanger 13, Ben.

3
00:00:13,656 --> 00:00:18,246
And I go way back to my first gig
in the industry at Midway Austin,

4
00:00:18,546 --> 00:00:22,176
as well as he is a Full Sail alumni.

5
00:00:22,313 --> 00:00:26,453
He has had a super interesting
career in development.

6
00:00:26,662 --> 00:00:30,682
Both in and around game
design, computer science.

7
00:00:30,756 --> 00:00:33,726
Science robotics engineering.

8
00:00:34,116 --> 00:00:34,926
You name it?

9
00:00:35,106 --> 00:00:39,156
He's had a hand in it or some
great thoughts to break down.

10
00:00:39,726 --> 00:00:42,576
On this episode, we talk about.

11
00:00:42,876 --> 00:00:44,106
Going Full Sail.

12
00:00:44,373 --> 00:00:48,423
Dave Arneson the creator
of Dungeons and dragons.

13
00:00:48,753 --> 00:00:51,993
We talk about what it's
like working at Lucas arts.

14
00:00:52,197 --> 00:00:53,667
We sit and talk about.

15
00:00:53,667 --> 00:00:58,437
The transistor and the gift
that was to modern society.

16
00:00:58,737 --> 00:01:03,177
We definitely go deep on AI and
some of the advancements and where

17
00:01:03,177 --> 00:01:06,507
that's going to take us and what
he's excited about into the future.

18
00:01:06,837 --> 00:01:08,487
And in particular on this one.

19
00:01:08,787 --> 00:01:14,247
A major initiative called dream week that
he had a big hand in bringing to fruition.

20
00:01:14,377 --> 00:01:15,997
For his company.

21
00:01:16,283 --> 00:01:18,863
coming to us from the bay area.

22
00:01:19,362 --> 00:01:21,612
Been Raton.

23
00:01:22,487 --> 00:01:24,017
Let's fall the fuck out.

24
00:01:26,657 --> 00:01:31,247
Catherine: Bienvenido Bienvenue Welcome
to the out of play area podcast, a

25
00:01:31,247 --> 00:01:35,837
show by video game devs for game devs,
where the guests open up one-on-one

26
00:01:35,837 --> 00:01:39,797
about their journey, their experiences,
their views, and their ideas.

27
00:01:40,487 --> 00:01:42,107
No ads, no bullshit.

28
00:01:42,467 --> 00:01:46,187
Join us as we venture far out
of the play area with your host

29
00:01:46,277 --> 00:01:48,437
seasoned game designer, John Diaz

30
00:01:50,734 --> 00:01:51,724
John: You've lived many lives.

31
00:01:52,216 --> 00:01:54,471
Ben R: I'm Jack of all
trades, but a master of none.

32
00:01:54,621 --> 00:01:56,181
John: Some people need
to be that way, man.

33
00:01:56,181 --> 00:01:58,281
You know, there's two ways to maximize

34
00:01:58,429 --> 00:02:00,319
Ben R: Well, you can go
deep when you go wide.

35
00:02:00,409 --> 00:02:05,719
And I go deep on certain things like AI
and game design, I go wide on things.

36
00:02:05,952 --> 00:02:07,242
John: It's been a minute, man.

37
00:02:07,242 --> 00:02:12,326
The last time I saw you was
down in the 30 ATX the legendary

38
00:02:12,326 --> 00:02:14,546
midway days, rest in peace.

39
00:02:14,799 --> 00:02:18,945
I still look back on those days and
can't even imagine like the wealth

40
00:02:18,945 --> 00:02:22,670
of talent, when we were juniors
mixed with the veterans, we had

41
00:02:22,670 --> 00:02:26,272
there to see like what everybody
would go on to work on and become

42
00:02:26,491 --> 00:02:27,541
I always look back, right.

43
00:02:27,541 --> 00:02:31,826
there's a, multi-verse reality
where we all stayed together like

44
00:02:31,886 --> 00:02:35,650
brought midway back to prominence
for the later part of the decade.

45
00:02:35,942 --> 00:02:38,890
Ben R: the six gyms, like, you
got your reality, you got, you

46
00:02:38,890 --> 00:02:39,807
know, everything you're doing.

47
00:02:39,807 --> 00:02:41,867
you know, I got, I got my mind gym, like,

48
00:02:42,427 --> 00:02:45,957
other people that are graphics and like,
you know, everything like aren't those

49
00:02:45,957 --> 00:02:48,291
like all just one piece to a giant puzzle.

50
00:02:48,612 --> 00:02:49,092
John: It's true.

51
00:02:49,302 --> 00:02:51,012
couldn't keep us together too long.

52
00:02:51,012 --> 00:02:51,342
Right?

53
00:02:51,372 --> 00:02:53,892
Like they had to be balanced
to the universe kind of thing.

54
00:02:54,302 --> 00:02:55,022
Ben R: Yeah, exactly.

55
00:02:55,022 --> 00:02:55,952
John: We had to be scattered.

56
00:02:56,081 --> 00:02:57,701
Ben R: we had to be a
part two to come back.

57
00:02:58,221 --> 00:02:58,881
John: Yes.

58
00:02:59,041 --> 00:03:02,131
Ben R: do imagine, like if we did
all come back together, though,

59
00:03:02,131 --> 00:03:03,568
we might break the universe.

60
00:03:05,838 --> 00:03:08,448
John: Those ships tomorrow's would
have to come sooner than later,

61
00:03:08,798 --> 00:03:11,198
Ben R: Oh, I mean, you know, I've
discovered water on Mars, right.

62
00:03:11,424 --> 00:03:13,734
John: Do every time you tell me
that I have to take a pause and

63
00:03:13,734 --> 00:03:15,924
be like, what was this guy doing?

64
00:03:16,284 --> 00:03:19,459
That he was already
experimenting and looking ahead.

65
00:03:19,605 --> 00:03:23,054
Ben R: was a young kid, you know, I
was great at math and science and like

66
00:03:23,054 --> 00:03:26,024
I got discovered by the right people
at the right time, you know, it was,

67
00:03:26,024 --> 00:03:29,072
that's the way I described luck everybody
has their own definition of luck.

68
00:03:29,072 --> 00:03:29,282
And my

69
00:03:29,312 --> 00:03:29,822
John: Sure.

70
00:03:29,852 --> 00:03:32,825
Ben R: of luck being at the right
place at the right time and knowing it.

71
00:03:33,125 --> 00:03:37,050
So like I was, self-conscious, I
was self-aware enough, like, even as

72
00:03:37,050 --> 00:03:40,789
a pre-teen between, I knew where I
wanted to go in life and I've always

73
00:03:40,789 --> 00:03:42,020
known that I wanted to make games.

74
00:03:42,020 --> 00:03:42,620
John: Where were you at this?

75
00:03:43,264 --> 00:03:44,374
Ben R: in Birmingham, Alabama.

76
00:03:44,404 --> 00:03:47,985
I grew up there we had an amazing
school system the year that I graduated

77
00:03:47,985 --> 00:03:51,757
our school in Birmingham JCI B the
Jefferson county and international

78
00:03:51,757 --> 00:03:56,351
baccalaureate school was founded for
Diplomats and for students that were

79
00:03:56,351 --> 00:04:00,991
coming over as part of that culture
like, because us degree, isn't even

80
00:04:00,991 --> 00:04:04,422
recognized internationally, like you
go to Spain, you go to France, you go

81
00:04:04,422 --> 00:04:07,058
to the UK, have a high school diploma.

82
00:04:07,058 --> 00:04:09,728
It's like third, but you have
a high school diploma from

83
00:04:09,728 --> 00:04:11,612
the U S what does that work?

84
00:04:11,792 --> 00:04:15,770
And so they made this whole program,
the JCB or IB program to make

85
00:04:15,770 --> 00:04:16,970
it internationally recognized.

86
00:04:16,988 --> 00:04:20,928
There was a whole IB
accreditation act sat scores.

87
00:04:21,118 --> 00:04:23,998
and actually we had the
highest act, sat scores.

88
00:04:23,998 --> 00:04:26,158
I was one of four people
that make perfect.

89
00:04:26,158 --> 00:04:26,818
Actsh

90
00:04:26,915 --> 00:04:28,970
John: What's that like, a 30,

91
00:04:29,296 --> 00:04:31,196
Ben R: you do it by taking it repeatedly.

92
00:04:31,331 --> 00:04:32,981
you don't get a perfect on your first try.

93
00:04:33,422 --> 00:04:36,011
John: they take the best
score of each category, right?

94
00:04:36,078 --> 00:04:36,408
Ben R: Yeah.

95
00:04:36,432 --> 00:04:39,492
you can perfect it that way, but there's
a true, perfect the same way that you

96
00:04:39,492 --> 00:04:43,632
get a true, like, you know, like a
skill on lock or you get an achievement.

97
00:04:43,662 --> 00:04:46,639
Like, was in lucky achievements
back in the day, like, you know,

98
00:04:46,669 --> 00:04:48,205
that were, real life achievements.

99
00:04:48,352 --> 00:04:52,130
so they, put us on the front of Newsweek
magazine actually their year I graduated.

100
00:04:52,130 --> 00:04:56,607
By the time I graduated, I think I'd taken
some like eight or 12, like AP classes.

101
00:04:56,616 --> 00:05:01,256
I went straight into being a sophomore
in college, but, it didn't mean anything

102
00:05:01,256 --> 00:05:05,486
because the skills that I wanted to
learn, they don't teach in college.

103
00:05:06,656 --> 00:05:09,326
fall sale is the first place that I
ever taught that actually taught me

104
00:05:09,506 --> 00:05:10,856
the skills that I actually needed.

105
00:05:11,062 --> 00:05:12,262
John: Well, the ones
that you wanted, right.

106
00:05:12,262 --> 00:05:13,192
To do the thing you wanted to do.

107
00:05:13,701 --> 00:05:14,301
Ben R: Exactly.

108
00:05:14,381 --> 00:05:16,121
it was a huge draw for me.

109
00:05:16,121 --> 00:05:18,601
with Dave working there,
like, you know, Dave burns.

110
00:05:19,261 --> 00:05:19,531
Yeah.

111
00:05:19,541 --> 00:05:23,205
The founder of D and D you know,
the, the true, true creative

112
00:05:24,477 --> 00:05:25,597
John: depending who you ask.

113
00:05:26,737 --> 00:05:28,531
Ben R: He is the job's to the Wazniak.

114
00:05:28,531 --> 00:05:32,027
He is the, guy who was the producer,
it's like, the person is going to take

115
00:05:32,027 --> 00:05:35,567
all the credit, you know it, while you
get your programmers in the background

116
00:05:35,567 --> 00:05:38,747
who are working hard, who are doing
the job, who are doing the heavy

117
00:05:38,747 --> 00:05:41,507
lifting, like who's that guy on G4.

118
00:05:41,537 --> 00:05:44,477
Who's that guy on, you
know, on the IGN interviews.

119
00:05:44,477 --> 00:05:47,747
Who's that guy at showing up
at , you know, he's up there.

120
00:05:47,837 --> 00:05:48,917
He's talking about the game.

121
00:05:48,917 --> 00:05:49,967
He's he's the hype man.

122
00:05:50,073 --> 00:05:50,793
he's the front man.

123
00:05:50,895 --> 00:05:51,637
here's a valuable.

124
00:05:52,327 --> 00:05:55,147
And I don't, I don't want to
discredit any producers or any

125
00:05:55,147 --> 00:05:57,697
executive producers, especially cause
I don't want to ever get like, you

126
00:05:57,697 --> 00:05:59,407
know, blacklisted from something.

127
00:05:59,559 --> 00:06:02,439
the producers that they have
a great role, but they don't

128
00:06:02,439 --> 00:06:03,699
understand the inner workings.

129
00:06:03,699 --> 00:06:06,099
They understand the,
the minuscule details.

130
00:06:06,099 --> 00:06:10,689
And I want it to go to full sail, to study
under somebody that taught the details

131
00:06:10,899 --> 00:06:14,049
that How has this pawn move in chess?

132
00:06:14,049 --> 00:06:18,899
How does a character move in, a Warhammer
because that's actually what Dave they've

133
00:06:18,899 --> 00:06:23,729
studied or that's what he did before
he ever made D and D most I've had the

134
00:06:23,729 --> 00:06:27,607
privilege, the honor, and the privilege
sitting down with him and talking

135
00:06:27,607 --> 00:06:28,865
with him while he was still around.

136
00:06:28,887 --> 00:06:31,557
And you know, when we used to
talk, I talked to him about

137
00:06:31,857 --> 00:06:34,714
what was it like making war top
gaming, and making that thing.

138
00:06:34,714 --> 00:06:37,444
Cause we're top gaming was
his bag back in the day.

139
00:06:37,672 --> 00:06:42,142
all these reenactments and you see
people pushing pawns around or, or

140
00:06:42,262 --> 00:06:43,865
pawns, but you see people pushing

141
00:06:43,959 --> 00:06:45,039
John: Pieces miniatures.

142
00:06:45,614 --> 00:06:46,754
Ben R: on the board.

143
00:06:46,855 --> 00:06:48,115
that was war, top gaming.

144
00:06:48,152 --> 00:06:51,392
that was the way the generals, that's
the way that people back in the day,

145
00:06:51,452 --> 00:06:55,174
like, you know, going back to Greek
times that people would bottle,

146
00:06:55,354 --> 00:06:58,136
like they would get reports from
the front, you know, the term Nike.

147
00:06:58,901 --> 00:06:59,381
John: Yeah.

148
00:06:59,466 --> 00:07:02,886
Ben R: You know that that's from
somebody running 26 and a half

149
00:07:02,886 --> 00:07:04,686
miles, like go fucking marathon.

150
00:07:05,046 --> 00:07:06,756
They want him back and then dying.

151
00:07:06,876 --> 00:07:10,027
Cause they're reporting back to their,
generals, they're reporting back to

152
00:07:10,027 --> 00:07:11,497
the they're saying victory, Nike.

153
00:07:11,501 --> 00:07:13,576
But like, you know, that's the
kind of stuff that he used to

154
00:07:13,576 --> 00:07:15,676
do and he inspired me so much.

155
00:07:15,691 --> 00:07:16,920
Like in the details.

156
00:07:16,920 --> 00:07:18,090
Everything is in the details.

157
00:07:18,316 --> 00:07:21,231
John: you got to full sail because
that's this place that was actually

158
00:07:21,231 --> 00:07:22,791
teaching game design and development.

159
00:07:22,791 --> 00:07:23,031
Right?

160
00:07:23,031 --> 00:07:26,151
I mean, I mean, there's a few options
at the time that seemed to be closer

161
00:07:26,151 --> 00:07:28,341
to your stomping grounds in Birmingham,

162
00:07:28,781 --> 00:07:31,307
Ben R: I recently heard one
of my ex professors Kayvon,

163
00:07:31,307 --> 00:07:32,359
Acosta Musharraf.

164
00:07:32,444 --> 00:07:33,404
John: Kayvon,

165
00:07:33,469 --> 00:07:33,785
Ben R: Yeah.

166
00:07:33,785 --> 00:07:37,220
he was talking to me like he was, he was
saying like, they've shifted their focus.

167
00:07:37,366 --> 00:07:38,866
split it into multiple tracks.

168
00:07:38,866 --> 00:07:41,746
So if you do want to be a producer,
if you want to be the high man, if you

169
00:07:41,746 --> 00:07:45,856
want to be the person who understands
production, because it is a valuable.

170
00:07:45,856 --> 00:07:46,352
skill, Like

171
00:07:47,536 --> 00:07:49,126
I've had to, learn how to do all at all.

172
00:07:49,275 --> 00:07:51,208
John: this place is in the,
in the industry that claim

173
00:07:51,208 --> 00:07:52,048
like, oh yeah, we're flat.

174
00:07:52,048 --> 00:07:52,978
We don't have producers.

175
00:07:52,978 --> 00:07:56,698
But all that really means is that
everybody wears a producer hat, right?

176
00:07:56,703 --> 00:07:56,963
Ben R: Yeah.

177
00:07:56,963 --> 00:08:00,773
Well, you still have to have, at the end
of the day, you have to have somebody

178
00:08:00,773 --> 00:08:02,423
that checks off all the boxes, right?

179
00:08:02,693 --> 00:08:05,273
Like even if you don't have a producer,
you always have a product owner.

180
00:08:05,538 --> 00:08:06,168
John: Yeah.

181
00:08:06,258 --> 00:08:09,428
Ben R: in scrum methodology, you have
like, you know, the scrum leader and then

182
00:08:09,428 --> 00:08:13,208
you have the product owner, like, you
know, agile, everybody talks about agile.

183
00:08:13,208 --> 00:08:15,068
Everybody talks about,
oh, we're super agile.

184
00:08:15,068 --> 00:08:19,161
It's like, yeah, that just means
that you don't want to like

185
00:08:19,161 --> 00:08:20,511
have organization sometimes.

186
00:08:21,715 --> 00:08:24,895
I think the best organization,
comes up around organically.

187
00:08:25,135 --> 00:08:25,915
It comes from.

188
00:08:27,640 --> 00:08:31,504
People taking the lead people,
taking charge you still have goals.

189
00:08:31,534 --> 00:08:36,504
So what I do today as a lead, because
that's my current position, I'm

190
00:08:36,514 --> 00:08:38,600
the lead AI and encounter designer.

191
00:08:38,619 --> 00:08:41,876
would I do is I work with my
directors, take their goals and I

192
00:08:41,876 --> 00:08:44,006
break those down into actionable tasks.

193
00:08:44,136 --> 00:08:44,406
John: Okay.

194
00:08:44,543 --> 00:08:47,909
Ben R: I, say to each one of the
people in my group, or I delegate

195
00:08:47,984 --> 00:08:51,524
out to another lead or give them
like what our requirements are.

196
00:08:51,824 --> 00:08:54,255
Like I say to them, like,
Hey, it's, sometimes it's like

197
00:08:54,285 --> 00:08:56,745
more a fearful or a femoral.

198
00:08:56,844 --> 00:09:02,454
You know, like we, as a director,
I want to see combat be good.

199
00:09:02,804 --> 00:09:05,034
It's like, what is combat good mean.

200
00:09:05,609 --> 00:09:07,529
John: Yeah, like a user
story kind of thing.

201
00:09:07,689 --> 00:09:08,139
Ben R: Yeah.

202
00:09:08,139 --> 00:09:09,639
you get this user story.

203
00:09:09,849 --> 00:09:12,699
And then as a leave, what you have to do
is you have to break it down and this is

204
00:09:12,699 --> 00:09:17,310
what production does, but  the disconnect
sometimes is, the production side.

205
00:09:17,310 --> 00:09:21,510
Doesn't understand always the
technical requirements, because

206
00:09:21,530 --> 00:09:25,110
they don't understand the, the
Dave Arneson kind of details.

207
00:09:25,140 --> 00:09:29,415
Like the little Snickers details is what
my creative writing teacher used to say,

208
00:09:29,535 --> 00:09:31,185
John: Snickers like the candy bar?

209
00:09:31,335 --> 00:09:31,785
Ben R: Yeah.

210
00:09:31,815 --> 00:09:34,674
Well, when you write a creative
writing paper, you say I went to

211
00:09:34,674 --> 00:09:35,934
the store and I got a candy bar.

212
00:09:36,284 --> 00:09:37,874
John: No, no, you got to fluff it.

213
00:09:39,794 --> 00:09:41,095
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

214
00:09:41,095 --> 00:09:43,484
Ben R: the creativeness is in the details.

215
00:09:43,754 --> 00:09:48,426
And sometimes that kind of detail gets
lost like across like production and

216
00:09:48,426 --> 00:09:50,416
design and it's not productions fault.

217
00:09:50,416 --> 00:09:54,876
Oftentimes like if you don't have a
producer that's embedded with you.

218
00:09:55,487 --> 00:09:59,479
if they're not with you, like you know,
if you don't have pods, like, is, is

219
00:09:59,479 --> 00:10:01,159
the terminology they use in scrum.

220
00:10:01,339 --> 00:10:04,940
Like if you don't have a a producer for
your pod, if they don't know every single

221
00:10:04,940 --> 00:10:08,510
day, every single person within that pod
is doing it and why they're doing it.

222
00:10:08,780 --> 00:10:12,077
And when it's like, when it can
be expected to be delivered, how

223
00:10:12,077 --> 00:10:15,227
can you expect anybody to produce
anything when they don't even

224
00:10:15,227 --> 00:10:16,487
know what they're talking about?

225
00:10:16,782 --> 00:10:17,322
John: Sure.

226
00:10:17,322 --> 00:10:17,592
Sure.

227
00:10:17,592 --> 00:10:19,812
I mean like what, what do you do
in cases where you like your team's

228
00:10:19,812 --> 00:10:22,362
kind of spread thin and, and, you
know, you've got to share producer

229
00:10:22,362 --> 00:10:23,442
across different features and

230
00:10:23,442 --> 00:10:23,892
strike teams.

231
00:10:24,012 --> 00:10:24,762
How do you get the

232
00:10:24,947 --> 00:10:27,617
Ben R: why we've got to step up,
we've got to step up and then they

233
00:10:27,617 --> 00:10:29,207
have to be the producers themselves.

234
00:10:29,207 --> 00:10:30,913
And that's what I've had to
do in several situations.

235
00:10:31,101 --> 00:10:33,219
been in a 300 person team.

236
00:10:33,399 --> 00:10:35,169
I've been in a three person team.

237
00:10:35,415 --> 00:10:37,695
seen the gambit, like I've
seen, I've seen, you know,

238
00:10:37,695 --> 00:10:39,105
the small teams of large team.

239
00:10:39,375 --> 00:10:43,425
And like I said, you gotta take off that
designer hat you put on the producer.

240
00:10:43,425 --> 00:10:46,545
I mean, you have to understand
what the constraints are.

241
00:10:46,785 --> 00:10:49,245
You have to understand what
the deliverable time is.

242
00:10:49,335 --> 00:10:54,195
You have to understand why is my director
asking for this in the first place?

243
00:10:54,195 --> 00:10:57,142
Because sometimes they
say, I want game good.

244
00:10:57,172 --> 00:10:59,602
But what they really mean is
I want you to improve things.

245
00:11:00,627 --> 00:11:01,677
John: Oh, yes.

246
00:11:01,738 --> 00:11:05,001
Ben R: you have to interpret that you
have to understand, but again, that's

247
00:11:05,001 --> 00:11:06,441
a, that's a level of communication.

248
00:11:06,591 --> 00:11:10,581
Like if you, if you have a,
hierarchy, like, okay, well

249
00:11:10,641 --> 00:11:11,751
you have a flat hierarchy.

250
00:11:11,751 --> 00:11:14,301
Does that mean that everybody's
talking to everybody all the time?

251
00:11:14,608 --> 00:11:16,138
I never felt a problem.

252
00:11:16,168 --> 00:11:18,988
Like, you know, I've, I've gotten in
trouble for this at some companies

253
00:11:19,408 --> 00:11:22,738
walking up to a person's office and
just being like, Hey dude, what's up

254
00:11:22,858 --> 00:11:25,948
like, you know, walking directly to
a person and asking them a question.

255
00:11:26,101 --> 00:11:28,561
some places, you know, they want
you to stay in your channel.

256
00:11:28,561 --> 00:11:33,091
They want you to, You know, swim in your
lane, like going up to the director of

257
00:11:33,091 --> 00:11:36,912
the game and just asking them like, Hey,
want to ask you about this in some ways.

258
00:11:36,912 --> 00:11:37,662
It isn't cool.

259
00:11:37,662 --> 00:11:40,842
Like, so when people talk about
flat hierarchy, I think what

260
00:11:40,842 --> 00:11:42,702
they mean is open communication.

261
00:11:42,872 --> 00:11:43,532
John: Yeah.

262
00:11:43,632 --> 00:11:46,145
Ben R: the same way that we
have open floor diagrams.

263
00:11:46,281 --> 00:11:46,431
John: Yeah.

264
00:11:46,431 --> 00:11:48,321
You can go anywhere to anybody.

265
00:11:48,526 --> 00:11:53,566
Ben R: Yeah, look well, well, I, I worked
in QA, but I worked in QA for a software

266
00:11:53,566 --> 00:11:55,889
development company did finance software.

267
00:11:55,979 --> 00:11:58,769
And if I walked up to the vice
president of the finance software

268
00:11:58,769 --> 00:12:01,199
company and I just walked into his
office and I was like, Hey dude,

269
00:12:01,199 --> 00:12:02,699
like, what do you want for this thing?

270
00:12:02,819 --> 00:12:05,189
He would do a chat me
down like in a second.

271
00:12:05,987 --> 00:12:06,407
John: man.

272
00:12:06,407 --> 00:12:10,757
I guess I can see that right on like
teams of like on massive teams where

273
00:12:11,105 --> 00:12:12,695
multiple people need to be in the know.

274
00:12:12,695 --> 00:12:16,235
And if you kind of go around these
little like checkpoints and stuff like

275
00:12:16,235 --> 00:12:19,775
that, then someone gets left out and
Hey, how come Ben knows this thing?

276
00:12:19,775 --> 00:12:22,955
And you didn't know, you know,
lead person or something like that.

277
00:12:23,180 --> 00:12:23,720
Ben R: Well, okay.

278
00:12:23,720 --> 00:12:25,400
So that's the reason
why we made discourse.

279
00:12:25,400 --> 00:12:29,840
That's the reason why slack exists is
to try to, you know, you know, all,

280
00:12:29,870 --> 00:12:32,711
all slack is IRC with an HTML five.

281
00:12:33,776 --> 00:12:38,134
like, like anybody who's been using
channels, like since the original

282
00:12:38,134 --> 00:12:42,628
newsgroups that were pre email, like,
you know, newsgroups were just, it's a

283
00:12:42,628 --> 00:12:47,278
thread and channel and, and that's like,
all we did was we made slack for gamers.

284
00:12:47,278 --> 00:12:48,448
Like when I was working on discord,

285
00:12:48,448 --> 00:12:49,768
John: well, it started for gamers, right.

286
00:12:49,768 --> 00:12:53,158
But now it's become just like
widely adopted for any community.

287
00:12:53,293 --> 00:12:56,653
Ben R: what we used to be doing is we
used to be writing bots like a, or Stan

288
00:12:56,701 --> 00:13:00,181
the, the lead, like a tech
guy over discord used to be

289
00:13:00,181 --> 00:13:02,371
writing bots for monitoring.

290
00:13:02,371 --> 00:13:06,687
When, when boss spawns would happen
in final fantasy 13, he would message

291
00:13:06,687 --> 00:13:10,317
them back to himself so that he can
log in and then like tamp this bonds.

292
00:13:10,527 --> 00:13:15,177
Like that was the reason why, why,
you know, he made all this stuff.

293
00:13:15,177 --> 00:13:16,887
And so he didn't have
to write those boxes.

294
00:13:17,312 --> 00:13:20,273
John: this instant necessity of something
kind of feeding technology, right.

295
00:13:20,273 --> 00:13:20,633
Or apps.

296
00:13:20,633 --> 00:13:22,073
And then other people get
their hands on a blue.

297
00:13:22,073 --> 00:13:23,333
I could also do other things.

298
00:13:24,003 --> 00:13:27,153
Ben R: But I mean, but, but games,
aren't always about necessity.

299
00:13:27,183 --> 00:13:31,773
They're about art and, and great art
is, is something that touches you.

300
00:13:31,773 --> 00:13:32,313
It moves you.

301
00:13:32,313 --> 00:13:37,863
It is you as a viewer are now or
experiencer in the case of games.

302
00:13:37,881 --> 00:13:42,454
But you as the player that you give them
agency, you give them the power to explore

303
00:13:42,600 --> 00:13:46,852
space, there was a talk, but there was
you know, in the defensive, like Siskel

304
00:13:46,852 --> 00:13:49,142
and Ebert back way back in the day, I

305
00:13:49,182 --> 00:13:49,552
think have.

306
00:13:49,872 --> 00:13:50,742
John: critics, man.

307
00:13:51,007 --> 00:13:51,267
Ben R: Yeah.

308
00:13:51,267 --> 00:13:52,027
Yeah, exactly.

309
00:13:52,152 --> 00:13:52,512
John: did they do?

310
00:13:52,512 --> 00:13:53,892
the, like the two thumbs up thing?

311
00:13:54,107 --> 00:13:54,847
Ben R: Our games.

312
00:13:54,847 --> 00:13:57,787
Aren't like, I don't think anybody
argues that any more is like, whether

313
00:13:57,877 --> 00:14:02,917
we, whether or not, when I say games, I
don't mean the art, the visuals of it.

314
00:14:02,917 --> 00:14:04,237
I don't mean the sound design.

315
00:14:04,237 --> 00:14:05,707
I don't mean the animation.

316
00:14:06,067 --> 00:14:11,247
Everybody look wholeheartedly Reese,
but do you consider the maker chess?

317
00:14:12,372 --> 00:14:12,582
So,

318
00:14:13,602 --> 00:14:15,042
John: DAS an interesting one, right?

319
00:14:15,042 --> 00:14:17,202
Because I mean, I would not, man.

320
00:14:17,202 --> 00:14:18,582
I would consider it well.

321
00:14:19,112 --> 00:14:21,332
Ben R: whoa, whoa,
dude, dude, like really?

322
00:14:21,542 --> 00:14:21,962
Okay.

323
00:14:22,022 --> 00:14:22,382
Come on.

324
00:14:22,622 --> 00:14:26,522
The person who wrote the rule,
set the person who said this, like

325
00:14:26,582 --> 00:14:28,742
modeling, that's what Dave did.

326
00:14:28,772 --> 00:14:29,552
That's what they did.

327
00:14:29,552 --> 00:14:31,472
And that's the reason why I
appreciate him as an artist.

328
00:14:31,562 --> 00:14:33,452
He said, this Palm moves forward.

329
00:14:33,542 --> 00:14:38,012
This is actually representative 15 real
people on the battlefield getting killed

330
00:14:38,012 --> 00:14:40,442
right now in our pawns quote, unquote.

331
00:14:40,682 --> 00:14:43,622
But they're the representative of
a group of people who are living,

332
00:14:43,622 --> 00:14:48,122
breathing, dying, just like you and me
like, but it's, it's the modeling and

333
00:14:48,122 --> 00:14:50,372
the modeling of system is an art form.

334
00:14:50,536 --> 00:14:52,876
John: I w when you break it
down like that, I will agree

335
00:14:52,876 --> 00:14:55,054
that that's an art, right?

336
00:14:55,054 --> 00:15:00,064
Like modeling something you see in the
world down to some like sweet contained

337
00:15:00,105 --> 00:15:03,260
finite rule set that, I think is

338
00:15:03,715 --> 00:15:07,395
Ben R: So one of my favorite
exercises to give someone who's on

339
00:15:07,395 --> 00:15:10,275
a job interview is like, make me a
game, make me a rule set right now.

340
00:15:10,515 --> 00:15:11,385
Here's your constraints.

341
00:15:11,385 --> 00:15:12,975
Here's what the, here's what the goal is.

342
00:15:13,088 --> 00:15:16,307
Cause you, you know, the
thing that defines toy versus.

343
00:15:16,374 --> 00:15:20,727
I used to talk to Fred Frederick Marcus,
who I was actually just looking up.

344
00:15:20,812 --> 00:15:24,965
One of his IGA talks yesterday Friday
Margaret is a great, brilliant game

345
00:15:24,965 --> 00:15:28,016
director used to work the motto you've
come around to people's desks and

346
00:15:28,016 --> 00:15:31,286
you'd sit down with them or, or maybe
it was just me because like he, would

347
00:15:31,286 --> 00:15:34,747
come around to my desk we'd sit down
and we talked for hours about anxiety,

348
00:15:34,747 --> 00:15:38,838
about game theory, about like what
makes a game, like Push yourself.

349
00:15:38,838 --> 00:15:40,488
How do you stress the system?

350
00:15:41,328 --> 00:15:44,981
if you're not stressing the system,
if you're not defining it, you

351
00:15:44,981 --> 00:15:48,184
can live in a, avoid, if you don't
push your bubble out, like how do

352
00:15:48,184 --> 00:15:49,414
you even understand the limits?

353
00:15:49,744 --> 00:15:50,902
But   rule set.

354
00:15:51,142 --> 00:15:54,922
So the, the thing that makes, and I
taught this at the academy of arts,

355
00:15:54,952 --> 00:15:57,202
when I was teaching game design to art.

356
00:15:57,202 --> 00:16:00,358
students which, which in itself
was a whole nother challenge.

357
00:16:00,568 --> 00:16:04,438
And especially considering several of
them were ESL students, like, you know,

358
00:16:04,468 --> 00:16:08,518
trying to teach somebody like where you're
struggling to communicate with them.

359
00:16:08,608 --> 00:16:12,049
And even basic conversation,  try to
teach them the most important thing.

360
00:16:12,079 --> 00:16:15,889
And what defines a game
is a victory condition or.

361
00:16:16,950 --> 00:16:21,210
until, you know, until, you know how
you can win and until, you know how you

362
00:16:21,210 --> 00:16:22,860
can lose, you can not have a strategy.

363
00:16:23,010 --> 00:16:24,600
You can't know how to get to that point.

364
00:16:24,690 --> 00:16:25,950
You don't even know what your goal is.

365
00:16:25,950 --> 00:16:30,330
You're shooting for the stars, you
have to have an end goal in order

366
00:16:30,330 --> 00:16:31,470
to understand how you get there.

367
00:16:31,770 --> 00:16:33,630
And that's, that's
where strategy comes in.

368
00:16:33,810 --> 00:16:36,720
And that's when you can find the
details where you can find the, how do

369
00:16:36,720 --> 00:16:41,010
I do this move and said that move and
there's opportunity costs of course,

370
00:16:41,190 --> 00:16:43,800
like one once you start to define, Okay.

371
00:16:43,920 --> 00:16:45,750
what are the actions
that players can take?

372
00:16:46,110 --> 00:16:49,620
Like once you have a goal and then
you can define the actions then,

373
00:16:49,680 --> 00:16:51,630
and only then can you have strategy?

374
00:16:51,940 --> 00:16:53,130
John: I mean, that's game theory, right?

375
00:16:53,130 --> 00:16:58,140
Like there's a big evolution
of competition winning, losing

376
00:16:58,170 --> 00:16:59,580
who's on top who's on bottom.

377
00:16:59,675 --> 00:17:03,997
Going back to being a lead, being
a designer through and through with

378
00:17:04,587 --> 00:17:08,883
different things from end-to-end bringing
the game to life, you've really attach

379
00:17:08,883 --> 00:17:11,283
yourself to like AI and encounters.

380
00:17:12,010 --> 00:17:13,417
Ben R: Only recently that's only recently.

381
00:17:13,417 --> 00:17:15,947
I've attached myself to several
things throughout my career.

382
00:17:15,994 --> 00:17:20,334
Like I thought I want to do boss,
like bosses because bosses were the

383
00:17:20,334 --> 00:17:25,483
scripted moments within like longer
cinematic games is what I would describe

384
00:17:25,483 --> 00:17:29,361
them as like when we, when we were
discovering like what 13, 13 was going

385
00:17:29,361 --> 00:17:32,061
to be, like, when I was working at
losers, we went through iterations.

386
00:17:32,061 --> 00:17:37,761
We were like we gears of, of star wars,
are we, you know like mass massive star

387
00:17:37,761 --> 00:17:41,571
wars, massive act like w we tried, we
tried on all these different hats that

388
00:17:41,611 --> 00:17:43,401
are all these different kinds of genres.

389
00:17:43,641 --> 00:17:46,671
And we try to see, you know,
which one was right for us.

390
00:17:46,671 --> 00:17:49,941
But, but when we settled in was
ultimately a cinematic shooter.

391
00:17:49,988 --> 00:17:51,908
But when I wanted to make those big.

392
00:17:52,084 --> 00:17:57,364
TV screen, or like now, like I think
with the streaming culture, like

393
00:17:57,364 --> 00:18:00,454
you can have them on your TV screen,
like the used to be cinematic screen.

394
00:18:00,454 --> 00:18:02,674
It used to be like, you
know, go into the movies.

395
00:18:02,798 --> 00:18:06,124
Like you know, those big moments of
like, why do you go to the movies?

396
00:18:06,124 --> 00:18:08,794
You, first of all, you go to make out
and like, you know, hang out with your

397
00:18:08,794 --> 00:18:09,994
girlfriend in the back of the theater.

398
00:18:10,234 --> 00:18:13,423
But like, you know you know, those,
those big like onscreen moments,

399
00:18:13,453 --> 00:18:15,523
the, the, the drastic parks,

400
00:18:15,788 --> 00:18:16,178
John: Yeah.

401
00:18:16,178 --> 00:18:16,358
Yeah.

402
00:18:16,358 --> 00:18:18,038
Those Hollywood blockbuster

403
00:18:18,091 --> 00:18:22,145
Ben R: you know, Jean's cameras, first
film was there ever was promised to,

404
00:18:22,295 --> 00:18:23,735
and he was one of three directors.

405
00:18:24,390 --> 00:18:30,360
John: damn D it's hard to see him
sharing directorial power with anyone.

406
00:18:30,360 --> 00:18:30,720
Yeah.

407
00:18:31,051 --> 00:18:34,441
Ben R: I felt really hurt when,
when Lucas arts got shut down, it

408
00:18:34,441 --> 00:18:38,848
was a, and now they're reopening it
as Lucasfilm games, which I'm, glad

409
00:18:38,848 --> 00:18:42,171
that they're re they're doing that,
but it's still, it was painful.

410
00:18:42,201 --> 00:18:42,771
It was painful.

411
00:18:42,771 --> 00:18:42,961
I,

412
00:18:42,961 --> 00:18:44,641
John: yeah, you thought you
were going to be there for life,

413
00:18:44,735 --> 00:18:45,995
Ben R: I was a Lucas lifer.

414
00:18:46,115 --> 00:18:46,385
I,

415
00:18:47,825 --> 00:18:51,275
my kids up like 10 years before they
were born for the daycare, they're

416
00:18:51,485 --> 00:18:54,785
like, that's how long the daycare
line was like, cause you got, I mean,

417
00:18:54,785 --> 00:18:56,105
diggers, it was crazy.

418
00:18:56,157 --> 00:18:56,696
John: In the states.

419
00:18:57,506 --> 00:19:00,256
Ben R: yeah, I was looking
at like, you know, like, like

420
00:19:00,315 --> 00:19:01,608
you know, establishing myself.

421
00:19:01,848 --> 00:19:05,688
My, my friend was working down
at jock Java, the hut, you

422
00:19:05,688 --> 00:19:07,218
know, down at our coffee shop.

423
00:19:07,292 --> 00:19:09,422
John: That's the name of the
coffee shop at Lucas arts.

424
00:19:09,482 --> 00:19:11,642
Ben R: yeah, well it was back in the day.

425
00:19:11,642 --> 00:19:14,312
I don't know, after COVID they
showed a bunch of shit down.

426
00:19:14,642 --> 00:19:17,051
They shut down sessions,
they shut down Java the hut.

427
00:19:17,051 --> 00:19:22,939
My friend was was the leader
the executive chef terminology.

428
00:19:22,939 --> 00:19:24,454
The executive chef over at sessions.

429
00:19:24,537 --> 00:19:26,757
Shout out to Dan, Dan, Dan beggars.

430
00:19:26,757 --> 00:19:28,207
He's buddy of mine.

431
00:19:28,207 --> 00:19:30,724
Like he's helped me through through
the best and worst of times.

432
00:19:30,773 --> 00:19:32,513
There was something
magic about that place.

433
00:19:32,573 --> 00:19:34,523
And I used to take people on tours.

434
00:19:34,523 --> 00:19:38,092
I used to walk them around the campus
and, you know, they shot one of the

435
00:19:38,092 --> 00:19:42,622
shots I'm like, I think from episode
two, like in the fountain garden, they're

436
00:19:42,622 --> 00:19:44,649
like they, edited it to hell and back.

437
00:19:44,649 --> 00:19:46,959
But it was a very special place
and it still is a special place.

438
00:19:46,959 --> 00:19:51,961
You have IRM there, you have all
of the moneymakers, which are, you

439
00:19:51,961 --> 00:19:53,071
know, how Lucas makes us money.

440
00:19:53,584 --> 00:19:54,934
John: Isn't it from

441
00:19:56,344 --> 00:19:58,114
Ben R: Yeah, merchandising merchandising.

442
00:19:58,114 --> 00:19:59,134
They said it in Spaceballs.

443
00:19:59,134 --> 00:20:01,024
We have the, we have
the star wars lunchbox.

444
00:20:01,024 --> 00:20:04,453
We have the storage bedroom, we have
the storage flame door, like there's

445
00:20:04,453 --> 00:20:05,713
a, there's an interesting story there.

446
00:20:05,713 --> 00:20:09,433
I won't go into it, but, but if anybody
wants to look it up online, there's an

447
00:20:09,433 --> 00:20:13,123
interesting story between, I think it was
Sony and Lucas at the time, like about

448
00:20:13,123 --> 00:20:15,463
how he couldn't make the second film.

449
00:20:15,463 --> 00:20:17,833
Cause he didn't have money in the
first film hadn't come out yet.

450
00:20:17,877 --> 00:20:20,912
But but that was, that was his thing
was that he was like, wow, I will,

451
00:20:20,952 --> 00:20:22,622
I will retain the licensing rights.

452
00:20:22,622 --> 00:20:24,322
And so Lucas licensing makes.

453
00:20:25,937 --> 00:20:30,298
We had to license our own character back
well, fortunately we had the licensed

454
00:20:30,298 --> 00:20:32,355
star killer from Lucas licensing.

455
00:20:32,415 --> 00:20:34,245
I shit, you not, this is a true story.

456
00:20:34,438 --> 00:20:36,088
go talk to the keeper of the Holocaust.

457
00:20:36,178 --> 00:20:38,322
There's also a guy he is
the keeper of the autograph.

458
00:20:38,622 --> 00:20:39,772
I'm like, who is who?

459
00:20:39,772 --> 00:20:41,152
Who's the head of licensing?

460
00:20:41,152 --> 00:20:42,400
Like the keeper of the whole ground.

461
00:20:42,430 --> 00:20:43,480
You have to go talk to him.

462
00:20:43,480 --> 00:20:47,290
And like we had to license our
own characters back for the sequel

463
00:20:47,440 --> 00:20:51,040
because they owned the characters
from the, from the first game.

464
00:20:51,100 --> 00:20:54,707
So that's the reason why if you ever
played fortunately shoe, you don't

465
00:20:54,707 --> 00:20:56,807
see any repeats except for circular.

466
00:20:57,013 --> 00:20:59,263
John: Because the
licensing hurdles to jump.

467
00:21:00,023 --> 00:21:03,113
Ben R: We, we would, we would
have to pay them to use our

468
00:21:03,113 --> 00:21:04,433
own characters that we created.

469
00:21:04,803 --> 00:21:05,073
John: Okay.

470
00:21:05,073 --> 00:21:05,553
So hold on.

471
00:21:05,883 --> 00:21:07,383
That seemed a little crazy.

472
00:21:07,383 --> 00:21:11,133
I kind of understand from like a business,
you know, Hey, this is the process.

473
00:21:11,133 --> 00:21:13,608
And to go around, it is, it
creates like an exception

474
00:21:13,608 --> 00:21:14,568
clause or something like that.

475
00:21:14,568 --> 00:21:16,818
But like you are Lucas arts.

476
00:21:16,848 --> 00:21:21,288
Is that not essentially like
first party to Lucas property?

477
00:21:21,411 --> 00:21:25,351
Ben R: Lucas film is the parent company
and Lucas Lucas film owns everything.

478
00:21:25,351 --> 00:21:30,822
So Lucas financing, Lucas arts, Lucas I'll
industrial light magic Skywalker sound.

479
00:21:30,839 --> 00:21:33,263
Who is the he has a
nonprofit organization.

480
00:21:33,263 --> 00:21:35,543
If you ever listened to NPR and he hears.

481
00:21:36,268 --> 00:21:40,101
Brought to you by this nonprofit,
like they do a lot of great

482
00:21:40,101 --> 00:21:43,145
things, but the moneymaker, the
people make all the money is

483
00:21:43,145 --> 00:21:43,535
licensing.

484
00:21:44,195 --> 00:21:44,375
Yeah.

485
00:21:44,405 --> 00:21:46,865
People ask like, why is
monkey island coming out?

486
00:21:46,865 --> 00:21:48,771
Why is, a day that I'd come now?

487
00:21:48,771 --> 00:21:49,821
why are they doing full title?

488
00:21:50,061 --> 00:21:51,021
Why are they doing link?

489
00:21:51,031 --> 00:21:52,871
TFCU where's the money come from?

490
00:21:52,871 --> 00:21:54,341
Like, how are they out there making it?

491
00:21:54,671 --> 00:21:58,841
And that was the even why they ended up
like chopping off, you know, sometimes

492
00:21:58,841 --> 00:22:01,772
you gotta chop off the armor, your
baby you know, to make a good game.

493
00:22:01,772 --> 00:22:05,164
The, there was something I learned at full
sail you know sometimes in order to ship

494
00:22:05,164 --> 00:22:09,580
or some sometimes in order to, to sell
to Disney you gotta, you gotta make some

495
00:22:09,580 --> 00:22:13,510
concessions and you have to, you know,
take out the least profitable section of

496
00:22:13,510 --> 00:22:17,949
organization cause, when Lucas started
and this is just hearsay, like what I've

497
00:22:17,949 --> 00:22:22,759
heard uncle George said was you know was
like, you know, just make it true, make

498
00:22:22,759 --> 00:22:26,858
it make a good and, and that that's, that,
that was one of The things that drew me

499
00:22:26,858 --> 00:22:31,148
to the organization in the first place was
that it was, The art for the sake of art,

500
00:22:31,314 --> 00:22:35,454
Art people don't recognize that
the creation of a rule set is

501
00:22:35,454 --> 00:22:38,574
an art form and it is unique.

502
00:22:38,604 --> 00:22:42,897
And it is like distinguishable,
like between products like there's

503
00:22:42,897 --> 00:22:46,534
can still be derivative art things
will be iterations on your rule set.

504
00:22:46,554 --> 00:22:49,524
I made up a game one time when I
didn't have enough chess pieces.

505
00:22:49,629 --> 00:22:52,689
And I didn't have enough checkers
pieces of, we made up a game called

506
00:22:52,719 --> 00:22:56,247
check checkers where it's like well,
for every chess piece, it moves like

507
00:22:56,247 --> 00:22:58,467
a chess piece, every chair piece,
it moves like a checker piece.

508
00:22:58,767 --> 00:23:01,647
And then at the beginning of
the game, you got to design your

509
00:23:01,647 --> 00:23:03,237
own, like starting rule set.

510
00:23:03,677 --> 00:23:04,797
You had to place the pieces.

511
00:23:04,887 --> 00:23:10,782
They had to be behind the second doc or
whatever, but like, just, just that that.

512
00:23:10,832 --> 00:23:14,852
slight modification of you can either
use checker pieces or chess pieces.

513
00:23:15,092 --> 00:23:18,842
And you can design like where they're
placed your initial Starting points

514
00:23:19,452 --> 00:23:21,526
That is Seventh dimension kind of shit.

515
00:23:21,556 --> 00:23:23,806
Like, you know, like string theory.

516
00:23:23,806 --> 00:23:27,166
Like if you want to go up to the 11th
dimension, like as you get higher

517
00:23:27,166 --> 00:23:29,839
and higher up the dimensions like,
cause like I was saying before, I

518
00:23:29,839 --> 00:23:31,249
did astrophysics for a long time.

519
00:23:31,399 --> 00:23:34,909
Like, I've thought about this, like
what are the rule sets of the world?

520
00:23:34,909 --> 00:23:35,179
Like, Well,

521
00:23:35,179 --> 00:23:36,289
you have basic physics.

522
00:23:36,289 --> 00:23:37,259
Like everything dropped.

523
00:23:38,464 --> 00:23:39,844
Well, you can change those.

524
00:23:40,024 --> 00:23:43,012
Like at a certain point, you've
gotten enough dimensions up.

525
00:23:43,192 --> 00:23:45,952
We were, it's not only about
the rule set, but it's also

526
00:23:45,952 --> 00:23:46,902
about the starting conditions.

527
00:23:46,902 --> 00:23:50,482
It's about like, what if we changed the
big bang, what the big bang was, was

528
00:23:50,492 --> 00:23:54,682
slightly bigger or slightly smaller, or
what if there were different elements

529
00:23:54,682 --> 00:23:56,122
that compose the bank, big bang.

530
00:23:56,332 --> 00:23:58,822
Our most common element in
the universe is hydrogen.

531
00:23:58,822 --> 00:24:00,232
That's how we get the red shift.

532
00:24:00,502 --> 00:24:02,752
That's how we, like, you know,
when you observe a disarm, you

533
00:24:02,752 --> 00:24:04,732
have to subtract out the hydrogen.

534
00:24:05,002 --> 00:24:08,092
Like what if the most common
element in the universe was oxygen?

535
00:24:08,332 --> 00:24:12,262
Well, what if we were nitrogen based
basically universe, like you start

536
00:24:12,262 --> 00:24:15,622
hitting into like banjos territory and
like, you know, multiple dimension,

537
00:24:15,622 --> 00:24:18,622
parallel dimension theory, but
when you're designing a game, you

538
00:24:18,622 --> 00:24:19,672
should think about it like that.

539
00:24:21,162 --> 00:24:25,812
I have this little pocket universe, I
have this little, this game I'm designing.

540
00:24:25,879 --> 00:24:26,895
And it, whoa, right.

541
00:24:26,895 --> 00:24:30,263
Actually talks a lot about this
about, you know, designing sport is

542
00:24:30,353 --> 00:24:34,013
about designing, you know, SIM city
was originally a helicopter game

543
00:24:34,013 --> 00:24:36,593
where you were going to fly over
and shoot things with a helicopter.

544
00:24:36,803 --> 00:24:41,503
And he found, he found that making the
city was more entertaining that the

545
00:24:41,573 --> 00:24:44,783
helicopter was going to fly over then
than actually the helicopter itself.

546
00:24:44,868 --> 00:24:45,228
John: All right, man.

547
00:24:45,228 --> 00:24:46,248
I've never heard that story.

548
00:24:46,248 --> 00:24:49,308
I've heard a lot of like
civilization, some city

549
00:24:49,628 --> 00:24:51,728
Ben R: He's he's he's
big out here in the bay.

550
00:24:51,758 --> 00:24:53,288
Like he's, he's based in Oakland.

551
00:24:53,362 --> 00:24:57,278
You know, he has, he has several projects
you know, that he does, and he does a

552
00:24:57,278 --> 00:24:59,654
lot of education outreach, you know?

553
00:24:59,710 --> 00:25:02,380
Well that was one of the nice things
about working the LucasArts they, they

554
00:25:02,380 --> 00:25:06,129
brought in these people, they brought in,
in Meyer, they brought in well, right.

555
00:25:06,129 --> 00:25:09,249
They brought in, you know, some
of the most simple games, ours,

556
00:25:09,579 --> 00:25:10,749
and I got to sit down with them.

557
00:25:10,749 --> 00:25:13,194
I got to sit down with Quentin
Tarantino and be like, when you were

558
00:25:13,194 --> 00:25:16,171
working on glorious bastards, how'd
you come up with the screenplay?

559
00:25:16,411 --> 00:25:19,171
And I got to talk to him about, he
was like, well, I went to this record

560
00:25:19,171 --> 00:25:22,531
shop and I was looking through these
albums and then like, I, the sound

561
00:25:22,531 --> 00:25:24,481
design is, is what he poses on first.

562
00:25:24,781 --> 00:25:27,751
Like, and, and, and, and if, if
you're, if you're trying to make a

563
00:25:27,751 --> 00:25:32,071
game or you don't know what game you're
making yet, I, I highly recommend.

564
00:25:32,756 --> 00:25:33,056
Right.

565
00:25:33,056 --> 00:25:37,829
The soundtrack first, come up with the
I mean, and also watch high-fidelity

566
00:25:37,834 --> 00:25:41,619
because you know John Cusack, he
describes it very well of you start

567
00:25:41,619 --> 00:25:45,219
out strong when you kick it up a
notch, then you draw it back before,

568
00:25:45,219 --> 00:25:46,999
so you don't blow your load too early.

569
00:25:47,011 --> 00:25:50,426
Then, then you, you do a slow
build up talker shadow, it's

570
00:25:50,426 --> 00:25:51,716
same thing as Shakespeare.

571
00:25:51,746 --> 00:25:56,786
Like if you even go back to the classic
three, like actual picture of like, oh,

572
00:25:56,816 --> 00:25:58,406
what are the major beats of your game?

573
00:25:58,406 --> 00:26:01,796
What are like, I mean, it's, it's,
again, it's fundamental theory.

574
00:26:01,832 --> 00:26:02,102
but.

575
00:26:02,159 --> 00:26:04,409
If you work the music, drive the pace,

576
00:26:04,769 --> 00:26:06,179
if you think about it that way.

577
00:26:06,599 --> 00:26:07,999
John: It's like pacing 1 0 1, man.

578
00:26:07,999 --> 00:26:10,429
You just kind of distilled
it down to its purest form.

579
00:26:10,429 --> 00:26:10,939
I like it.

580
00:26:11,384 --> 00:26:16,214
Ben R: as a multi-talented multi, you
know, instrumentalist, I play music, I

581
00:26:16,214 --> 00:26:18,464
do games like, you know, it's like jazz.

582
00:26:18,464 --> 00:26:21,794
So, you know, like you can't just
like, let it be free form or whatever.

583
00:26:21,794 --> 00:26:25,144
Like I, I personally prefer
a pop song over jazz.

584
00:26:25,202 --> 00:26:27,734
You know, you can't just do off.

585
00:26:27,764 --> 00:26:28,094
Yeah.

586
00:26:28,154 --> 00:26:31,718
A little bit of structure helps
the audience understand the message

587
00:26:31,748 --> 00:26:34,978
that you're trying to get a message
across like, what is your takeaway?

588
00:26:35,578 --> 00:26:39,360
And, and I asked this to
Brian Sharp, but you know

589
00:26:39,655 --> 00:26:40,255
John: Yeah.

590
00:26:40,279 --> 00:26:41,149
Dude, Brian Sharp.

591
00:26:41,149 --> 00:26:42,439
I got to connect with that guy.

592
00:26:42,624 --> 00:26:46,194
Ben R: I asked him like, he was
telling me about meditation or yoga,

593
00:26:46,404 --> 00:26:47,624
and I was like, what's the takeaway?

594
00:26:47,624 --> 00:26:49,284
And he's like, what

595
00:26:49,829 --> 00:26:49,949
John: Yeah,

596
00:26:52,344 --> 00:26:53,994
Ben R: my mind is so

597
00:26:54,004 --> 00:26:54,534
focused.

598
00:26:54,749 --> 00:26:56,339
John: and max many times, the point.

599
00:26:56,339 --> 00:26:57,059
When am I going to get out of

600
00:26:57,294 --> 00:27:01,224
Ben R: Well, you know, that, that's
what we, as, you know, you know, apex

601
00:27:01,224 --> 00:27:05,664
predators slash, you know, survivalists,
you know, whatever you want to define

602
00:27:05,664 --> 00:27:10,209
your personal, like human gameplay as
being but you know, w we, we look for.

603
00:27:10,914 --> 00:27:14,724
And because you know, why we went
for veterans is because it actually

604
00:27:14,724 --> 00:27:16,524
takes our brain less energy.

605
00:27:17,004 --> 00:27:20,244
Like if you, if you are, have to think
about something, if you had to process

606
00:27:20,244 --> 00:27:24,894
something, thinking calories, it takes
calories, you actually have to think

607
00:27:24,894 --> 00:27:27,264
harder and then it, you burn energy in.

608
00:27:27,324 --> 00:27:29,544
And so what we try to do
is we try to find patterns.

609
00:27:29,544 --> 00:27:30,804
We try to find similarities.

610
00:27:31,074 --> 00:27:35,609
And so we are big brain, like, you
know, theory it creates these neural

611
00:27:35,609 --> 00:27:40,109
pathways and neuroscientists talk
about this all the time about the

612
00:27:40,109 --> 00:27:44,309
midmaxing and the optimization of,
of finding patterns within society.

613
00:27:44,609 --> 00:27:48,809
And so that the Genova Chen actually
talks about like the flow state, a

614
00:27:48,809 --> 00:27:52,362
bunch, and like, you know, to get
into a flow state, you have to like

615
00:27:52,692 --> 00:27:56,652
get those like neural pathways built,
but then you have to alter them.

616
00:27:56,791 --> 00:27:57,571
John: yes,

617
00:27:57,597 --> 00:28:00,687
Ben R: it's, Mario and the turtle,
like the very first level of Mario,

618
00:28:00,687 --> 00:28:04,087
if if you just, if you don't touch
the controller, Mario runs forward.

619
00:28:04,657 --> 00:28:05,587
I don't know if you've ever tried this?

620
00:28:05,587 --> 00:28:05,917
poor.

621
00:28:05,917 --> 00:28:08,427
Like it was, it was something
that was brought up to me in,

622
00:28:08,427 --> 00:28:09,667
in a different game design talk.

623
00:28:10,117 --> 00:28:13,147
If Mario just runs for, he runs
straight into the first Moomba cause

624
00:28:14,047 --> 00:28:15,967
is, is, is right under three blocks.

625
00:28:15,967 --> 00:28:17,524
And there's a fourth block on top of it.

626
00:28:17,548 --> 00:28:20,639
if you did nothing, first of
all, you can't run backwards.

627
00:28:20,789 --> 00:28:21,809
So pushing the

628
00:28:21,874 --> 00:28:22,234
John: screen.

629
00:28:23,419 --> 00:28:28,061
Ben R: but I want to, I want to be very
clear, just like quantum theory, like

630
00:28:28,061 --> 00:28:30,341
the absence of input is still an input.

631
00:28:30,641 --> 00:28:32,171
Like the, like the

632
00:28:32,201 --> 00:28:32,651
absence.

633
00:28:32,786 --> 00:28:34,076
John: your zero case, right?

634
00:28:34,166 --> 00:28:35,156
Ben R: it's, it's quantum theory.

635
00:28:35,156 --> 00:28:37,046
It's, it's a  box.

636
00:28:37,346 --> 00:28:40,623
It's, it's a, you know, the, the cat
you know when you look inside the boxes

637
00:28:40,623 --> 00:28:44,983
that are alive or dead, the cat poor
cat, what let's say, you know, it's

638
00:28:44,987 --> 00:28:46,027
John: look inside the box.

639
00:28:46,377 --> 00:28:46,677
Ben R: something.

640
00:28:46,677 --> 00:28:50,937
So, so it's, it's something that, that has
less like a, an emotional attachment, you

641
00:28:50,937 --> 00:28:54,529
know if you look inside the box, you have
a bit, yet you had a coin, either have

642
00:28:54,529 --> 00:28:58,099
a coin, or you don't have a coin because
cats are much more valuable than that,

643
00:28:58,959 --> 00:28:59,409
John: Amen.

644
00:28:59,659 --> 00:29:02,419
Ben R: but by not looking in
the box, that's how that's.

645
00:29:02,659 --> 00:29:06,379
So I have, I have one, one
tattoo on my wrist, and this

646
00:29:06,379 --> 00:29:07,429
is the most important thing.

647
00:29:07,429 --> 00:29:12,651
I know your viewers can't see
it, but the most important it is

648
00:29:12,651 --> 00:29:15,344
what's called a PNP transistor.

649
00:29:15,344 --> 00:29:19,678
It has an input, it has a connection
and it has an output it's also

650
00:29:19,708 --> 00:29:21,178
referred to as a type of switch.

651
00:29:21,239 --> 00:29:24,220
Basically, so you can either
switch it on or off, but.

652
00:29:24,351 --> 00:29:24,831
connection.

653
00:29:24,861 --> 00:29:28,011
It's the most basic form of a transistor.

654
00:29:28,451 --> 00:29:30,791
And it's what we have millions
of inside of your phone,

655
00:29:30,801 --> 00:29:32,091
inside, everything that you do.

656
00:29:32,144 --> 00:29:34,124
It's the most important
invention since the plow.

657
00:29:34,334 --> 00:29:36,494
I talk about this a lot and sometimes,

658
00:29:36,564 --> 00:29:38,124
John: kind of has a plow shape though.

659
00:29:38,154 --> 00:29:39,414
That's the crazy thing about it?

660
00:29:39,748 --> 00:29:42,638
Ben R: well, all the plow allowed
us to become an industrialized

661
00:29:42,648 --> 00:29:44,028
like civilized society.

662
00:29:44,119 --> 00:29:45,264
my mentor Mr.

663
00:29:45,264 --> 00:29:46,610
Hollis rest in peace.

664
00:29:46,686 --> 00:29:50,822
You know, he, he, he taught me
about the fundamentals electronics.

665
00:29:51,093 --> 00:29:54,763
Again, this goes back to like, why,
why would, why do I think I was more

666
00:29:54,763 --> 00:29:56,383
successful than my counterparts?

667
00:29:56,418 --> 00:29:59,556
You know, going through, you know,
programming and stuff like that, like

668
00:30:00,396 --> 00:30:02,286
is because I was taught robotics.

669
00:30:02,286 --> 00:30:04,206
I was taught, you know,
from the ground up.

670
00:30:04,236 --> 00:30:10,067
I, I, I had the privilege and honor of, of
being part of a, you know, a program which

671
00:30:10,067 --> 00:30:15,338
was the pre-computer and, and engineering
program that was developed by, by Mr.

672
00:30:15,338 --> 00:30:20,005
Hollis as a, as a alternative
education kind of thing.

673
00:30:20,665 --> 00:30:24,895
he recognized that the high schools
were not teaching computer science.

674
00:30:24,895 --> 00:30:26,095
They were not teaching.

675
00:30:26,120 --> 00:30:29,240
He, he was one of these
punchcard guys back in the

676
00:30:29,455 --> 00:30:30,295
John: Oh, gosh.

677
00:30:30,865 --> 00:30:30,925
Yeah.

678
00:30:31,060 --> 00:30:34,370
Ben R: he, we I've seen the
stacks of punch cards and how we

679
00:30:34,370 --> 00:30:35,900
like used to program computers.

680
00:30:36,085 --> 00:30:39,685
John: the old G miles and
miles of punch cards, feeding

681
00:30:39,685 --> 00:30:41,485
instructions, all bits, right.

682
00:30:41,485 --> 00:30:42,025
You just kind of

683
00:30:42,415 --> 00:30:42,955
on and off,

684
00:30:43,020 --> 00:30:45,894
Ben R: drop a stack in there,
like like my entire evening.

685
00:30:47,869 --> 00:30:49,729
John: you know, it happened,
you know, it happens,

686
00:30:49,729 --> 00:30:49,969
man,

687
00:30:50,214 --> 00:30:50,454
Ben R: no.

688
00:30:50,744 --> 00:30:54,384
There's lots of war stories from
the war room of like, you know,

689
00:30:54,384 --> 00:30:57,414
being, being in your, you know, in
the zone, you're trying to develop,

690
00:30:57,444 --> 00:31:00,594
you're trying to hit a deadline and
then you dropped the stack of cards.

691
00:31:00,646 --> 00:31:01,104
But he,

692
00:31:01,599 --> 00:31:03,529
John: in like what we do today,

693
00:31:03,529 --> 00:31:05,763
Ben R: You, you delete,
you delete the repository.

694
00:31:06,388 --> 00:31:08,428
John: oh God, well, you
can always recover that,

695
00:31:08,428 --> 00:31:08,728
right?

696
00:31:08,728 --> 00:31:09,118
Like,

697
00:31:09,413 --> 00:31:10,383
Ben R: No, not, not.

698
00:31:10,383 --> 00:31:13,593
You delete your local repository,
you delete the repository,

699
00:31:14,013 --> 00:31:15,243
the remote repository.

700
00:31:15,408 --> 00:31:15,858
John: which,

701
00:31:16,203 --> 00:31:17,883
Ben R: imagine you deleted your get hub.

702
00:31:18,288 --> 00:31:18,888
John: oh my God,

703
00:31:18,967 --> 00:31:19,957
permissions, Maine.

704
00:31:20,118 --> 00:31:22,436
Ben R: No, that would be the good one
today, but what I was trying to get

705
00:31:22,436 --> 00:31:27,234
at, and I think a message I want to
send you to your listeners is, is that,

706
00:31:27,474 --> 00:31:31,763
you know, the transition is the most
important invention in the last 100 years.

707
00:31:32,333 --> 00:31:37,433
And an interest is how we taught rocks to
think is the way I describe it to people.

708
00:31:37,703 --> 00:31:38,483
It's it is the,

709
00:31:38,708 --> 00:31:39,098
John: who's the,

710
00:31:39,098 --> 00:31:39,678
rock.

711
00:31:39,678 --> 00:31:40,580
Ben R: The rock is the courts.

712
00:31:40,580 --> 00:31:44,975
It's the crystal, it's the you know it's,
the transition is made out of Silicon.

713
00:31:46,055 --> 00:31:47,705
It's how the silicone is.

714
00:31:47,755 --> 00:31:50,548
Crystal is technically a
rock like you know, the, the

715
00:31:50,548 --> 00:31:50,908
planet.

716
00:31:51,253 --> 00:31:51,523
John: right?

717
00:31:51,523 --> 00:31:51,943
Like

718
00:31:52,498 --> 00:31:55,858
Ben R: Have you ever thought about
the rock that we live on is just a big

719
00:31:55,858 --> 00:31:57,238
enough rock that we can't jump off it?

720
00:31:58,753 --> 00:32:02,263
John: ha, because is that because of the
gravitational pull because of the size

721
00:32:02,608 --> 00:32:05,458
Ben R: Yeah, it matters.

722
00:32:05,458 --> 00:32:06,448
It really matters.

723
00:32:06,508 --> 00:32:07,228
It matters a lot.

724
00:32:07,723 --> 00:32:09,733
John: ketchup off this damn rock?

725
00:32:09,788 --> 00:32:10,938
Ben R: Yeah, it's just a rock.

726
00:32:11,228 --> 00:32:12,938
It's so big that you can't jump off it.

727
00:32:13,005 --> 00:32:18,181
But like every single, every single
thing that's inside of a a computer well,

728
00:32:18,211 --> 00:32:23,043
there's the, so Jay tag, the joint task
action group, or the, are the people that

729
00:32:23,043 --> 00:32:25,128
made the original integrated circuit.

730
00:32:25,148 --> 00:32:28,534
I see they're the people that
made the Silicon base, like,

731
00:32:29,044 --> 00:32:29,944
you know, kind of things.

732
00:32:30,244 --> 00:32:33,304
And, and it's funny now because
I've done weighing into the hacker

733
00:32:33,304 --> 00:32:37,182
community, there's J tag connections on
everything in your phone and you're in

734
00:32:37,182 --> 00:32:39,153
your water heater and your everything.

735
00:32:39,153 --> 00:32:42,423
Like you can, you can, you can tap
into these J tech ashes and if you know

736
00:32:42,423 --> 00:32:46,373
the fundamentals of electronics and
computer circuitry, you can actually.

737
00:32:46,935 --> 00:32:51,422
D compile, like the instructions are
being sent, like, along those, those

738
00:32:51,422 --> 00:32:52,802
things, that's how people hack phones.

739
00:32:52,802 --> 00:32:54,482
That's how people do all this shit.

740
00:32:54,524 --> 00:32:59,654
but at the fundamental level, all it is
is a, not courts, but silicone-based,

741
00:32:59,654 --> 00:33:01,445
you know, crystal, like you know

742
00:33:01,445 --> 00:33:03,665
why quantum computing is so big now?

743
00:33:03,725 --> 00:33:04,835
Why it's so important?

744
00:33:05,311 --> 00:33:06,961
John: always looked at it
as just like kind of the,

745
00:33:07,201 --> 00:33:09,726
massive leap  processing that.

746
00:33:10,333 --> 00:33:10,903
Achieve

747
00:33:10,903 --> 00:33:11,263
with it.

748
00:33:11,546 --> 00:33:12,806
Ben R: Where's that massive?

749
00:33:12,806 --> 00:33:14,096
We've been processing come from.

750
00:33:14,411 --> 00:33:19,020
John: I mean, I, I imagine like there's
some crazy jump across the number of

751
00:33:19,020 --> 00:33:20,910
cores that you're sandwiching together.

752
00:33:21,009 --> 00:33:23,079
Ben R: See, that's the
old school thinking.

753
00:33:23,289 --> 00:33:26,169
So the reason do you know why we
sandwich course together in the.

754
00:33:27,014 --> 00:33:28,364
John: I guess we're just
running out of space.

755
00:33:28,364 --> 00:33:29,804
So we, we started going vertical.

756
00:33:29,952 --> 00:33:34,971
Ben R: an electron, if you can only
make a channel so narrow, so, so

757
00:33:34,971 --> 00:33:38,931
tiny, so compact before the electrons
start jumping channels, where they

758
00:33:38,931 --> 00:33:42,621
start dropping between the left
side, as we can watch multi-core

759
00:33:42,621 --> 00:33:46,221
processing came about was because we
were, we were hitting Moore's law.

760
00:33:46,251 --> 00:33:47,361
We were hitting the maxes.

761
00:33:47,841 --> 00:33:51,681
You know, you're not able to accelerate
the process any faster because we

762
00:33:51,681 --> 00:33:53,001
made them as small as we could.

763
00:33:53,151 --> 00:33:55,491
And literally electrons
are jumping back and forth.

764
00:33:55,636 --> 00:33:57,226
John: And then he he issue right.

765
00:33:57,226 --> 00:33:58,096
Heat in space.

766
00:33:58,281 --> 00:33:59,241
Ben R: he heating space.

767
00:33:59,271 --> 00:34:04,649
Yeah, definitely the heat increases the
positive charge and then it is outward.

768
00:34:04,649 --> 00:34:06,435
It's a by-product of,
the, positive church.

769
00:34:06,524 --> 00:34:10,672
But the electrons were jumping
across channels in the, in the when

770
00:34:10,672 --> 00:34:14,032
they try to make these, you can
only make them a molecule thick,

771
00:34:14,282 --> 00:34:14,852
John: Yeah,

772
00:34:15,282 --> 00:34:16,072
Ben R: as volume of.

773
00:34:16,112 --> 00:34:17,432
John: size we can get to.

774
00:34:17,432 --> 00:34:21,422
Ben R: so quantum computing came about
because of the fact that they, they

775
00:34:21,452 --> 00:34:23,672
now have reached, they're starting to.

776
00:34:23,672 --> 00:34:25,843
at least like we're going
to plateau on Moore's law.

777
00:34:26,023 --> 00:34:29,743
If we don't, if we don't actually
have a way to make things that

778
00:34:29,743 --> 00:34:31,483
are smaller than a molecule,

779
00:34:31,663 --> 00:34:31,873
Like

780
00:34:32,563 --> 00:34:34,033
you, when you started
going into the subatomic

781
00:34:34,313 --> 00:34:35,783
John: we got to change
the game now, right?

782
00:34:35,783 --> 00:34:37,973
Like how the ha how we approach
and how we build in this.

783
00:34:38,012 --> 00:34:38,342
Ben R: okay.

784
00:34:38,432 --> 00:34:40,610
So there's two major
game-changers in that.

785
00:34:41,653 --> 00:34:45,493
How the fuck do you maintain that
without a giant cooling system?

786
00:34:45,793 --> 00:34:51,043
Like when I was working on, on the
Mars rovers, like we had a whole liquid

787
00:34:51,103 --> 00:34:55,731
nitrogen cooling system for any of our
stuff, but but if you want to go so

788
00:34:55,731 --> 00:35:00,671
atomic, like if you want to go, you
know, particle, smasher, like level

789
00:35:00,671 --> 00:35:05,678
like you, you first of all one of the
huge gains is that you now are working

790
00:35:05,678 --> 00:35:10,658
with a Triny system I'm bringing it
all back, like to use cat, you know,

791
00:35:10,658 --> 00:35:15,278
the important thing about like, I I'm
saving this risk, my other risks for, the

792
00:35:15,308 --> 00:35:17,348
first quantum pocket, quantum computers,

793
00:35:17,438 --> 00:35:18,968
John: caught fall where you think we are.

794
00:35:20,313 --> 00:35:22,683
Ben R: last hundred years, I think
I'll, I'll see it before I die.

795
00:35:22,923 --> 00:35:23,853
like I think we're going to go

796
00:35:24,178 --> 00:35:24,538
John: Hi.

797
00:35:24,568 --> 00:35:25,228
I like that.

798
00:35:25,473 --> 00:35:26,343
Ben R: past a hundred years

799
00:35:26,643 --> 00:35:27,813
anyway, so

800
00:35:27,818 --> 00:35:29,158
John: give me, give me a goal, man.

801
00:35:29,158 --> 00:35:32,848
Like stay healthy, stay low, stay
alive, long enough to see this thing.

802
00:35:33,328 --> 00:35:34,168
See what people do with it.

803
00:35:34,168 --> 00:35:36,866
Cause the civilization is going
to move at a ridiculous pace.

804
00:35:36,866 --> 00:35:38,546
Once that comes together like that.

805
00:35:38,762 --> 00:35:40,862
Ben R: we've solved the disease of aging.

806
00:35:40,906 --> 00:35:43,772
aging is just a disease, like, you
know, the same way than anything else.

807
00:35:43,772 --> 00:35:48,476
The disease, we've been able to figure out
how to stop like cells from degenerating.

808
00:35:48,506 --> 00:35:51,986
Like when you, when cell split, they
degenerate and then like, that's the

809
00:35:51,986 --> 00:35:55,596
reason why we have a finite lifetime,
but quantum computing doing back to

810
00:35:55,596 --> 00:35:59,118
the topic quantum computing, one of the
things I like about it is that it is

811
00:35:59,118 --> 00:36:03,318
trinary system and setting the binary
system in serving ones and zeros, which

812
00:36:03,318 --> 00:36:04,878
is what we described as electrons.

813
00:36:04,908 --> 00:36:06,198
Like, you know, one zeros jumping

814
00:36:06,413 --> 00:36:07,613
John: Positive negative here.

815
00:36:07,878 --> 00:36:09,679
Ben R: positive, negative that,
that's what this is all about.

816
00:36:09,679 --> 00:36:12,229
That's what the PNP
transistor is all about.

817
00:36:12,229 --> 00:36:15,109
It's like, if you don't put anything
in, you know, it doesn't connect.

818
00:36:15,109 --> 00:36:15,979
If you put something in.

819
00:36:16,949 --> 00:36:18,619
But that's that's binary, that's it?

820
00:36:18,619 --> 00:36:19,979
That's where the ones zeros come from.

821
00:36:19,979 --> 00:36:24,849
That's like literally the basis of
all binary is, is, is a transistor.

822
00:36:24,893 --> 00:36:27,143
but with quantum computing,
now you have a trinary system.

823
00:36:27,293 --> 00:36:30,893
Now you have one zero, or
I have not yet observed it.

824
00:36:31,280 --> 00:36:34,550
the act of not observing
it is, is in itself a

825
00:36:34,550 --> 00:36:34,970
state

826
00:36:35,340 --> 00:36:36,120
John: there we go.

827
00:36:36,470 --> 00:36:38,990
Ben R: state that can be
used in quantum computing.

828
00:36:39,015 --> 00:36:41,725
they talk about this in string
theory and about and about this

829
00:36:41,725 --> 00:36:44,344
and quantum computing, like
theory if you've ever taken.

830
00:36:44,393 --> 00:36:47,903
There's some great courses online,
by the way, if you, if you were

831
00:36:47,903 --> 00:36:52,500
interested in quantum computing they
offer them for free from MIT and

832
00:36:52,500 --> 00:36:56,970
from Stanford and from Berkeley, like
there are all these great, like every

833
00:36:56,980 --> 00:36:59,686
online quantum computing courses that
I recommend you go check them out.

834
00:36:59,805 --> 00:37:00,225
John: I'm with it.

835
00:37:00,225 --> 00:37:02,595
So like, if I'm bringing it down
into, like, let's say I'm writing

836
00:37:02,595 --> 00:37:05,655
a scripting node, I'm breaking
it down and you know, there's a,

837
00:37:06,015 --> 00:37:09,092
there's an on, off and uh, not here

838
00:37:09,092 --> 00:37:09,392
yet.

839
00:37:10,052 --> 00:37:10,892
Not yet observed.

840
00:37:10,892 --> 00:37:11,402
Okay.

841
00:37:11,712 --> 00:37:13,880
Is there a symbol, Is there
a symbol, for that state?

842
00:37:13,899 --> 00:37:15,009
there like a ASCII.

843
00:37:16,097 --> 00:37:18,367
Ben R: no I'm saving my
other risks for that symbol.

844
00:37:18,367 --> 00:37:21,217
Like there, there, there are, there
are a couple of diagrams online,

845
00:37:21,217 --> 00:37:22,722
like wa but they're conflicting.

846
00:37:23,528 --> 00:37:24,968
John: No, one's standardized it yet.

847
00:37:25,168 --> 00:37:28,292
Ben R: you know, the second, most
important thing of quantum computing so

848
00:37:28,322 --> 00:37:31,232
the, the way that we normally transfer
information around the world right

849
00:37:31,232 --> 00:37:32,552
now is through fiber optic, right?

850
00:37:33,512 --> 00:37:33,692
Yeah.

851
00:37:33,722 --> 00:37:34,202
Through light.

852
00:37:34,262 --> 00:37:36,542
And so what, what is faster
than the speed of light?

853
00:37:36,819 --> 00:37:37,509
John: I don't know.

854
00:37:37,769 --> 00:37:37,949
Ben R: Y.

855
00:37:39,514 --> 00:37:42,934
So through the, there, the actual quantum
entanglement, we can actually beat this

856
00:37:42,934 --> 00:37:44,464
beautiful boy through, through that.

857
00:37:44,464 --> 00:37:48,364
Like that's the reason why it comes from
abusers so fast is they move faster.

858
00:37:48,394 --> 00:37:51,214
It's it's, it's the first everybody
talks about like, you know, like,

859
00:37:51,244 --> 00:37:52,504
oh, star Trek and everything.

860
00:37:52,504 --> 00:37:57,244
It's like, no, we, we actually
have measurable quantifiable, like

861
00:37:57,350 --> 00:38:00,110
the, the only way they can do it
as they shoot a beam of light.

862
00:38:00,320 --> 00:38:02,840
And then, and then they see
that it's faster than the light.

863
00:38:02,942 --> 00:38:06,264
they they shot it across a lake
with like a 50 mile wide lake.

864
00:38:06,534 --> 00:38:10,464
And then you can see that the particle
got there faster than the beam of light.

865
00:38:10,704 --> 00:38:14,304
Like we have scientific ways of
measuring light and we have scientific

866
00:38:14,304 --> 00:38:16,464
ways of measuring quantum entanglement.

867
00:38:16,674 --> 00:38:21,114
And so I could communicate with China
faster, the speed of light right now.

868
00:38:21,144 --> 00:38:22,674
Like if I had a quantum entanglement.

869
00:38:23,848 --> 00:38:26,218
John: Okay, bro, you just, you
just broke it down for me, man.

870
00:38:26,218 --> 00:38:26,728
It's a try.

871
00:38:26,728 --> 00:38:31,438
And every system that opens up a
whole nother factor of outputs and

872
00:38:31,438 --> 00:38:36,688
instructions and that moves faster
than the speed of light, which I

873
00:38:36,688 --> 00:38:41,502
didn't even know was an element or like
that's not you can't, it's not even.

874
00:38:42,507 --> 00:38:44,187
Ben R: The way you do is
by folding dimensions.

875
00:38:44,217 --> 00:38:47,187
You go through the, through the fourth
dimension, up to the fifth dimension,

876
00:38:47,187 --> 00:38:50,667
and then like, by, by having the
two portables that are entangled,

877
00:38:50,877 --> 00:38:52,407
like you, can you full dimensions?

878
00:38:52,407 --> 00:38:53,811
That's the only way you can get faster.

879
00:38:53,811 --> 00:38:54,711
And then the third dimension.

880
00:38:55,157 --> 00:38:55,577
John: Okay.

881
00:38:55,577 --> 00:39:00,467
I understand at a high level with
my caveman brain, I understand the,

882
00:39:00,467 --> 00:39:05,717
the, the core elements of quantum
computing and how bring it back

883
00:39:05,717 --> 00:39:08,207
to from the transistor to this new

884
00:39:08,587 --> 00:39:08,857
Ben R: Yeah.

885
00:39:08,927 --> 00:39:09,407
John: get here.

886
00:39:10,107 --> 00:39:10,347
Ben R: Yeah.

887
00:39:10,627 --> 00:39:12,487
But let let's let's talk about games.

888
00:39:12,807 --> 00:39:14,187
John: Let's talk about games, man.

889
00:39:14,487 --> 00:39:19,167
After that, that making games is easy,
bro, let's go back to making games.

890
00:39:19,367 --> 00:39:22,617
Ben R: Yeah, let's stop solving
really quantum entanglement.

891
00:39:22,987 --> 00:39:24,187
John: But this is exciting, right?

892
00:39:24,217 --> 00:39:24,757
This society.

893
00:39:24,787 --> 00:39:27,787
Cause I definitely wanted to
ask you if like, are we going?

894
00:39:27,787 --> 00:39:32,137
Where can we get to, and, and is
even quantum computing, like within

895
00:39:32,137 --> 00:39:34,447
the foreseeable future and how
the would that change what we do?

896
00:39:34,447 --> 00:39:38,273
So, I mean, let people noodle on
that and as speculate and we can

897
00:39:38,273 --> 00:39:39,653
always talk about that in the future.

898
00:39:39,653 --> 00:39:42,023
Cause that's just a topic that's not going
to go anywhere where you're just going

899
00:39:42,023 --> 00:39:44,663
to keep getting closer and then figuring
out all the different applications of it.

900
00:39:44,663 --> 00:39:50,603
But for people today, coming to you and
admiring what we do, what you built,

901
00:39:50,793 --> 00:39:50,973
Ben R: Okay.

902
00:39:51,063 --> 00:39:52,953
Well, so everything is just a tool, right?

903
00:39:53,793 --> 00:39:54,633
It doesn't matter.

904
00:39:54,633 --> 00:39:56,823
It doesn't matter how
fast your computer is.

905
00:39:56,823 --> 00:39:59,853
Like, you know, the fastest gaming rig
that doesn't make you the greatest games.

906
00:40:00,718 --> 00:40:05,059
Like design is about like
experiential it's about agency.

907
00:40:05,419 --> 00:40:09,649
And, and it's the difference between
a book and a movie versus a game

908
00:40:09,889 --> 00:40:14,209
like is a passive media versus
an active media in through games.

909
00:40:14,209 --> 00:40:18,109
And through interactive entertainment,
we can build engagement and

910
00:40:18,109 --> 00:40:20,419
we can build these neurons,
like firing through our brain.

911
00:40:20,419 --> 00:40:23,419
But every, every step of the way,
that's kind of like, what I was trying

912
00:40:23,419 --> 00:40:27,623
to get at originally was, was we as
game designers, what we do is we build

913
00:40:27,714 --> 00:40:32,004
hurdles, we build hurdles and you have
to be able to jump over that hurdle.

914
00:40:32,304 --> 00:40:35,034
If I made a 10 meter high
hurdle for three foot.

915
00:40:35,984 --> 00:40:37,604
You're not going to be
able to jumper bearable.

916
00:40:38,294 --> 00:40:40,244
You may have to make achievable goals.

917
00:40:40,268 --> 00:40:44,978
It's a, it's a systematic pattern and
it follows the Shakespearian method

918
00:40:45,218 --> 00:40:50,490
of, you know like give people, agency,
give them like power, give them, or

919
00:40:50,490 --> 00:40:54,163
at least some of the best games that
I've experienced do this pattern.

920
00:40:54,163 --> 00:40:55,596
They, they, they give you agency.

921
00:40:55,866 --> 00:41:02,376
They give you the ability as a player
to be able to enact that agency, to, to

922
00:41:02,494 --> 00:41:04,414
show what I would call it, player skills.

923
00:41:04,504 --> 00:41:08,614
So you have the player skills and as an ag
designer, like if we want to get back on

924
00:41:08,614 --> 00:41:13,014
the topic of AI design, like what I have
to do as an AI designer and in what I do

925
00:41:13,144 --> 00:41:16,144
every day is I make achievable hurdles.

926
00:41:16,354 --> 00:41:18,231
Like I make a challenge.

927
00:41:18,416 --> 00:41:19,046
John: skills.

928
00:41:19,341 --> 00:41:20,301
Ben R: Yes, exactly.

929
00:41:20,631 --> 00:41:23,558
So, so if if the player
skill is Dodge, right.

930
00:41:24,288 --> 00:41:24,648
I do.

931
00:41:24,708 --> 00:41:28,758
I give you a bowl that runs straight
at you and you have to learn, you

932
00:41:28,758 --> 00:41:31,788
have to learn, oh, like it's going
to keep charging straight at you

933
00:41:31,938 --> 00:41:33,348
and you have to Dodge left or right.

934
00:41:33,618 --> 00:41:38,178
Like, it's a, it's an achievable goal,
but, but it's, it's testing your mastery

935
00:41:38,388 --> 00:41:40,668
of the ability to Dodge left or right.

936
00:41:40,728 --> 00:41:41,388
John: Yes.

937
00:41:41,566 --> 00:41:46,936
with what you do today, Ben, how hands-on
are you versus kind of more managerial?

938
00:41:46,966 --> 00:41:48,466
Is that up to you?

939
00:41:48,526 --> 00:41:51,468
Do you get to pick what
approaches do you have for that?

940
00:41:51,498 --> 00:41:51,948
What do you like?

941
00:41:51,948 --> 00:41:52,758
What do you wish you would be

942
00:41:53,053 --> 00:41:59,224
Ben R: I am a big believer in leading
by example and, and my managerial

943
00:41:59,224 --> 00:42:01,594
skill is I get in there every day.

944
00:42:01,684 --> 00:42:03,604
I would never ask anybody to do something.

945
00:42:03,634 --> 00:42:07,025
I wouldn't be able to do myself
or couldn't do myself, or can you

946
00:42:07,025 --> 00:42:10,221
be working with reduction or, or
if you don't have production, how

947
00:42:10,221 --> 00:42:11,451
can you be a producer yourself?

948
00:42:11,601 --> 00:42:14,511
If you can't understand the, the, the
amount of time it would take to do

949
00:42:14,511 --> 00:42:17,012
something or whether or not it is a.

950
00:42:17,012 --> 00:42:21,682
Known unknown or if it's an unknown,
unknown, like an unknown, unknown is

951
00:42:21,682 --> 00:42:23,767
basically in the production process.

952
00:42:23,767 --> 00:42:27,729
You have your pie in the sky, you
have, you know approve produce.

953
00:42:27,744 --> 00:42:30,564
And some people call these things
like L gates or some people call

954
00:42:30,564 --> 00:42:31,728
them like, you know, different?

955
00:42:31,769 --> 00:42:36,929
Like milestones or whatever, but,
you know, you have, you have like the

956
00:42:36,959 --> 00:42:40,059
seven, seven piece I think is what
we call it or something like that.

957
00:42:40,065 --> 00:42:45,131
You know pine sky proof or pre-production
improved produce then you have the

958
00:42:45,216 --> 00:42:49,610
ship and you have the, the final
post-production like shippers

959
00:42:49,610 --> 00:42:53,295
only is the only one that doesn't
follow the P methodology, you have

960
00:42:53,295 --> 00:42:55,165
these very clearly defined phases.

961
00:42:55,212 --> 00:42:59,143
If you can't get over that initial
hurdle, if if you're a game designer

962
00:42:59,263 --> 00:43:03,673
and if you're a fledgling game designer,
what, what I've seen people struggle

963
00:43:03,673 --> 00:43:07,873
with and I've I at being a teacher,
being a professor, being a person who's

964
00:43:07,873 --> 00:43:13,093
analyzed games again, again, like I
always say, well, what is your goal?

965
00:43:13,363 --> 00:43:16,857
What is your, and we talked about this
at the beginning, bringing it back you

966
00:43:16,857 --> 00:43:21,147
know, what is your win or lose condition
until you have a winner lose condition?

967
00:43:21,147 --> 00:43:22,437
You don't know where going.

968
00:43:22,677 --> 00:43:26,157
and then, and only then can, can you
define the where the player skills.

969
00:43:26,957 --> 00:43:30,979
Because not every Mario can, you
know, jump in three dimensions.

970
00:43:30,979 --> 00:43:35,179
Like some can only jump in two dimensions,
like, like until you give the player

971
00:43:35,179 --> 00:43:40,279
power until you give them that agency,
like you can't start to begin to define

972
00:43:40,401 --> 00:43:45,345
what are the obstacles that you have to
like present to them an AI and the AI?

973
00:43:45,390 --> 00:43:49,167
Well again, shout, shout out to
Sergio OCO he was a big believer

974
00:43:49,167 --> 00:43:53,423
in you know, AI should be the, the
world's best, second place finisher.

975
00:43:55,228 --> 00:43:57,988
John: all week always like right
on your tail, right on your tail.

976
00:43:58,403 --> 00:44:01,363
Ben R: He should always be something
that is challenging, but that is.

977
00:44:02,633 --> 00:44:06,203
It is, it is something that
you, you can do, but each should

978
00:44:06,203 --> 00:44:07,973
always be achievable to do.

979
00:44:07,973 --> 00:44:12,233
And it should be like increasing
itself over time, like, as you

980
00:44:12,233 --> 00:44:13,343
were getting better as a player.

981
00:44:13,403 --> 00:44:17,158
So, so there are two types of games
like or actually there's three types

982
00:44:17,158 --> 00:44:20,575
of games there's social games board and
card games, and then video games, like

983
00:44:20,995 --> 00:44:24,997
that's a whole nother thing, but but,
but within video games within that, that

984
00:44:24,997 --> 00:44:28,323
third spectrum there are, there are two
types of games and th they're you know

985
00:44:28,385 --> 00:44:31,014
ones where you increase your player skill.

986
00:44:31,404 --> 00:44:35,650
So things like super meat boy things
like you know, we're, we're in order

987
00:44:35,650 --> 00:44:40,084
to achieve success, like you know
binding of Isaac, like you have to

988
00:44:40,264 --> 00:44:42,784
not level yourself up as a character.

989
00:44:42,904 --> 00:44:44,794
You have to level yourself up as a person.

990
00:44:45,274 --> 00:44:46,714
Like you got to get.

991
00:44:47,509 --> 00:44:51,229
Like, there's no way you can beat
this next level unless you get better.

992
00:44:51,379 --> 00:44:53,179
Not, not my stats are getting higher.

993
00:44:53,179 --> 00:44:54,829
Like it's not a massive act.

994
00:44:54,829 --> 00:44:58,429
It's not a, oh, well, I just went and
grind it out like a final fantasy.

995
00:44:58,429 --> 00:44:58,669
Right?

996
00:44:58,879 --> 00:45:00,379
You go, you can't be the boss.

997
00:45:00,499 --> 00:45:01,339
You go grind it up.

998
00:45:01,369 --> 00:45:01,939
You go, you

999
00:45:02,014 --> 00:45:02,764
John: stats up.

1000
00:45:02,839 --> 00:45:04,099
Ben R: stat up your character.

1001
00:45:04,369 --> 00:45:06,379
Like you're leveling up
here during not living up.

1002
00:45:06,379 --> 00:45:07,249
you as a person.

1003
00:45:07,249 --> 00:45:08,689
You're not learning new skills.

1004
00:45:08,899 --> 00:45:11,299
You're not learning how
to be a better combatant.

1005
00:45:11,539 --> 00:45:14,689
You're not learning how to defeat the
boss more effectively, where all you're

1006
00:45:14,689 --> 00:45:16,069
doing is you're standing past it.

1007
00:45:16,309 --> 00:45:19,339
And that's, that's increasing
the, the stats of the character.

1008
00:45:19,519 --> 00:45:21,289
It's not increasing
your skill as a player.

1009
00:45:21,289 --> 00:45:21,511
John: Yeah.

1010
00:45:21,541 --> 00:45:22,801
Putting in your reps, right?

1011
00:45:22,801 --> 00:45:24,811
Just constant repetition,
like exercise, right?

1012
00:45:24,811 --> 00:45:26,941
Like building the muscle, just
doing it over and over and over.

1013
00:45:27,181 --> 00:45:30,031
Getting your timing down your
extremity down your reaction,

1014
00:45:30,791 --> 00:45:31,091
Ben R: Right.

1015
00:45:31,151 --> 00:45:35,471
We imagine, imagine it, I mean, there are,
there are some apps that do this now it's

1016
00:45:35,471 --> 00:45:38,831
like, imagine every rep it's like, oh,
we're going to wrap this like bar belt.

1017
00:45:38,861 --> 00:45:40,931
Now you're going to rep this,
like pull up and get a rep this

1018
00:45:40,931 --> 00:45:43,211
thing, every single thing is, yeah.

1019
00:45:43,361 --> 00:45:46,751
Well, just like building your body,
building your mind, you gotta,

1020
00:45:46,811 --> 00:45:48,221
you gotta be holistic about it.

1021
00:45:48,221 --> 00:45:51,641
You can't just like, you know, work
the same thing over and over again.

1022
00:45:51,851 --> 00:45:55,571
You have to ask to actually try
yourself, test yourself, like, you

1023
00:45:55,571 --> 00:45:58,871
know, push yourself in all these
different dimensions and all, all the

1024
00:45:58,871 --> 00:46:01,241
11 dimensions, like a quantum computing.

1025
00:46:02,176 --> 00:46:06,616
John: What is kind of like the
most exciting development in

1026
00:46:06,616 --> 00:46:08,566
AI that you've seen in a while.

1027
00:46:08,961 --> 00:46:13,311
Ben R: Oh, well, well we'll, I don't know
if you know, but we're way, way behind.

1028
00:46:13,401 --> 00:46:16,201
I mean, and like, that's the reason
why I got into hacking recently.

1029
00:46:17,226 --> 00:46:22,053
Well, no, I mean, well, no, I, I
especially is, you know, is they, now

1030
00:46:22,053 --> 00:46:26,718
have, they now have access to quantum
computing in, in some areas in the

1031
00:46:26,718 --> 00:46:30,288
weather utilizing it for, and, and
what they're doing is, is so there's

1032
00:46:30,288 --> 00:46:31,548
different types of machine learning.

1033
00:46:31,788 --> 00:46:37,548
So AI, AI, AI is, is a whole
field, but it's, AI is a super set.

1034
00:46:37,548 --> 00:46:41,786
It's a larger set of of you know,
different types of subsets and

1035
00:46:41,786 --> 00:46:44,786
where we're all the, the most like,
you know, advancements from being

1036
00:46:44,786 --> 00:46:46,046
made right now is machine learning.

1037
00:46:46,406 --> 00:46:48,506
But people are not applying.

1038
00:46:48,830 --> 00:46:49,890
As well as they could.

1039
00:46:49,930 --> 00:46:52,570
You know, I have, I have my own
developments I've been doing for, for

1040
00:46:52,570 --> 00:46:56,261
the last five years, even before it was
a two K like on, on machine learning

1041
00:46:56,261 --> 00:46:59,261
architecture and how to make a game
engine that's based on machine learning,

1042
00:46:59,261 --> 00:47:03,499
RJ architecture, but machine learning
again, that is a super set it's like,

1043
00:47:03,529 --> 00:47:07,028
okay, well, within machine learning,
you have, you have imitation learning.

1044
00:47:07,028 --> 00:47:09,434
You have there's there's
about like 12 different types.

1045
00:47:09,484 --> 00:47:13,972
The, the important part is that there
are so many different types of machine

1046
00:47:13,972 --> 00:47:18,430
learning that you can do now that are
based on, Chu learning or deep learning.

1047
00:47:18,490 --> 00:47:20,750
Where will you take large set of data?

1048
00:47:20,960 --> 00:47:24,110
And this is where the data mining
processing companies come from.

1049
00:47:24,110 --> 00:47:25,790
This is where your fake spokes come from.

1050
00:47:25,790 --> 00:47:28,160
This is where your Amazon's
come from, but, but they're,

1051
00:47:28,160 --> 00:47:29,960
they're way behind Alibaba.

1052
00:47:30,170 --> 00:47:31,640
They're way behind Tencent.

1053
00:47:31,766 --> 00:47:35,812
in China, like the coolest thing I saw
at GC this past year, and the coolest

1054
00:47:35,812 --> 00:47:37,822
AI I saw was a thing called Wu Kong.

1055
00:47:37,882 --> 00:47:39,562
AI, if you haven't seen it, look it up.

1056
00:47:39,862 --> 00:47:44,696
It's basically they made w U K
O and G like the monkey king.

1057
00:47:44,906 --> 00:47:46,356
It's a it's in some mythology.

1058
00:47:46,356 --> 00:47:49,022
But a Wu Kong AI it was it's it's,

1059
00:47:49,022 --> 00:47:51,623
John: Dennis, like Pete's a team of pros.

1060
00:47:51,743 --> 00:47:52,433
Okay.

1061
00:47:52,543 --> 00:47:52,903
Ben R: Yeah.

1062
00:47:52,993 --> 00:47:56,533
Team of pros as well, because it
has to use reinforcement learning.

1063
00:47:56,533 --> 00:47:58,633
It has to use has used imitation learning.

1064
00:47:58,633 --> 00:48:01,054
It has to use team-based group tactics.

1065
00:48:01,804 --> 00:48:05,314
You have to you the same way
that I give a player agency.

1066
00:48:05,674 --> 00:48:08,494
When I make a AI, it's called an agent.

1067
00:48:09,124 --> 00:48:11,974
So the agent is the thing that has agency.

1068
00:48:12,274 --> 00:48:16,654
Like I make an AI agent, it has agency
the same way I give a player agency.

1069
00:48:16,654 --> 00:48:19,144
Like I can model like a player
versus like these things.

1070
00:48:19,444 --> 00:48:21,814
But like, up until this point,
there are certain things.

1071
00:48:21,910 --> 00:48:25,399
I don't know if you know about like
capture and recapture and like recapture

1072
00:48:25,399 --> 00:48:29,149
to the reason why you now have to
pick out like stop signs or whatever

1073
00:48:30,494 --> 00:48:32,204
John: We'll take the little
thing in the right direction.

1074
00:48:32,424 --> 00:48:32,684
Yeah.

1075
00:48:33,019 --> 00:48:34,579
Ben R: all you're doing
is you're training AI.

1076
00:48:34,579 --> 00:48:39,919
There, you, you are training AI every
time you do a recapture, like look it up.

1077
00:48:40,069 --> 00:48:42,902
Like they that's how they, they
catalog every single library.

1078
00:48:43,692 --> 00:48:47,622
Now they have a, they, they got
the, you know, the London library,

1079
00:48:47,622 --> 00:48:49,242
they got the, New York times.

1080
00:48:49,422 --> 00:48:52,862
They, they, and they were able to
categorize the New York times in, in

1081
00:48:52,872 --> 00:48:54,772
like a, you know, a matter of weeks.

1082
00:48:54,772 --> 00:48:57,823
Because, because there's certain
things that the computers can do

1083
00:48:57,823 --> 00:49:02,023
better than humans, but, but through
reinforcement learning and through

1084
00:49:02,023 --> 00:49:04,273
imitation learning is what it's called.

1085
00:49:04,321 --> 00:49:07,291
We can actually train computers to
do the things that they can't do.

1086
00:49:07,501 --> 00:49:12,691
So we're, we're, we're making AI right
now that that are better than us.

1087
00:49:12,691 --> 00:49:15,181
But the only reason why they're
better than us is because we

1088
00:49:15,181 --> 00:49:16,261
don't have infinite memory.

1089
00:49:16,711 --> 00:49:17,821
When you go to sleep at night,

1090
00:49:17,881 --> 00:49:20,371
John: Ram gets flushed bro,
or committed to long-term

1091
00:49:20,371 --> 00:49:20,641
memory.

1092
00:49:20,641 --> 00:49:21,031
Yeah.

1093
00:49:21,901 --> 00:49:23,731
Ben R: your short-term memory.

1094
00:49:23,761 --> 00:49:26,761
your mental long-term memory, but you
don't have an infinite hard drive space.

1095
00:49:26,881 --> 00:49:29,221
You get a terabyte up your, up your brain.

1096
00:49:29,641 --> 00:49:33,871
Like you can either add more storage
space, like it's not expendable storage.

1097
00:49:33,941 --> 00:49:36,131
John: I like to think, man, you
know, what's the elastic enough,

1098
00:49:36,161 --> 00:49:39,311
Mary, you can kind of keep building
and stretching it and building those

1099
00:49:39,311 --> 00:49:40,271
neurons, but you're right, right.

1100
00:49:40,271 --> 00:49:43,091
Like things that you don't, you
can't test everything constantly.

1101
00:49:43,091 --> 00:49:43,271
Right.

1102
00:49:43,271 --> 00:49:46,091
So things that you haven't used in a
while are going to kind of fade away.

1103
00:49:46,091 --> 00:49:46,481
Right.

1104
00:49:46,517 --> 00:49:49,337
Ben R: the whole machine learning
architecture, it's, it's basically,

1105
00:49:49,487 --> 00:49:51,947
if you've ever written a recursive
algorithm, like you understand

1106
00:49:51,977 --> 00:49:55,173
how machine learning works, it's
a, what's it called Markov chain.

1107
00:49:55,368 --> 00:49:59,958
the idea is that instead of
having memory, what you do is you

1108
00:49:59,958 --> 00:50:02,058
collapse the memory into a single.

1109
00:50:03,013 --> 00:50:06,493
And it's like, I don't have a
brain that can remember everything.

1110
00:50:06,553 --> 00:50:10,633
I have a brain that can only hold
so much, but if I change it every

1111
00:50:10,633 --> 00:50:15,623
day by using like what I've learned
today, in order to affect like the,

1112
00:50:15,623 --> 00:50:18,493
the current state of it, then that,
that is, that is machine learning.

1113
00:50:18,583 --> 00:50:22,183
Like literally all we did is we said,
well, what did we take this thing,

1114
00:50:22,183 --> 00:50:24,433
that has infinite space when we
give it a limited amount of space.

1115
00:50:24,463 --> 00:50:27,313
And now with the limited amount of
space we have to rewrite and you have

1116
00:50:27,313 --> 00:50:32,323
to like, change the rules the way that
it approaches something like every day.

1117
00:50:32,372 --> 00:50:34,622
John: What I've always enjoyed
about AI design, right?

1118
00:50:34,622 --> 00:50:37,172
It's kind of surprising the player, right?

1119
00:50:37,172 --> 00:50:40,802
That's what I've always kind of
pursued whenever I'm down deep

1120
00:50:40,802 --> 00:50:44,432
in some behavior trees or goat
models or whatever like that.

1121
00:50:44,797 --> 00:50:48,301
what applications for games
are you excited about?

1122
00:50:48,405 --> 00:50:53,002
Ben R: think the most exciting things
are, I guess, looking at going, I is like,

1123
00:50:53,032 --> 00:50:56,242
if you played against like competitive
players and if you've played against

1124
00:50:56,242 --> 00:51:00,442
like real-world players, modeling real
world players, I think that like any

1125
00:51:00,472 --> 00:51:04,342
person who's into competitive gaming,
like, you know, we, we do this whole

1126
00:51:04,642 --> 00:51:07,402
survey where it's like, what are you
like, what type of game are you aware?

1127
00:51:07,402 --> 00:51:08,242
You're a casual player.

1128
00:51:08,284 --> 00:51:10,775
impeditive player you
a a story drone player.

1129
00:51:10,775 --> 00:51:13,938
Like, you know, we, we have like all
this modeling that we do, like within my

1130
00:51:13,938 --> 00:51:17,238
company, like in order to, find our target
demographic, that's a big part of like,

1131
00:51:17,238 --> 00:51:20,518
you know, selling games and marketing
games is finding your target demographic.

1132
00:51:20,518 --> 00:51:21,268
So it depends.

1133
00:51:21,268 --> 00:51:22,858
It depends on what your demographic is.

1134
00:51:22,917 --> 00:51:24,557
it's a multifaceted question.

1135
00:51:24,720 --> 00:51:25,320
what is the best?

1136
00:51:25,320 --> 00:51:29,126
AI is the best AI, is what is
matched to that player style.

1137
00:51:29,606 --> 00:51:31,226
Like it has to, it depends
on your player style.

1138
00:51:31,346 --> 00:51:35,842
If you are a solo driven story
person, then like the best thing

1139
00:51:35,842 --> 00:51:39,892
for you is going to be a series of
hurdles they're slightly higher.

1140
00:51:40,102 --> 00:51:43,102
And that drop back down the,
give you a sense of power

1141
00:51:43,102 --> 00:51:44,482
at the end of every chapter.

1142
00:51:44,632 --> 00:51:47,692
So you complete a game, you go through
the first act of the game, you get

1143
00:51:47,692 --> 00:51:51,232
really strong and then you go into
the second act and you just demolish

1144
00:51:51,262 --> 00:51:53,062
everything and, you know, great.

1145
00:51:53,212 --> 00:51:55,252
Cause you're like, oh, well I
completed the first chapter.

1146
00:51:55,342 --> 00:51:56,212
Here's my reward.

1147
00:51:56,212 --> 00:51:58,663
Here's my, extrinsic and intrinsic reward.

1148
00:51:58,663 --> 00:52:03,133
Like I'm both more powerful stat
wise and more powerful as a player.

1149
00:52:03,215 --> 00:52:07,717
you get that, adrenaline, Russia that
dopamine release because, The game

1150
00:52:07,717 --> 00:52:11,647
has shown you the, Hey, you completed
this thing that was really difficult.

1151
00:52:12,007 --> 00:52:14,331
And so that's how you make solo games.

1152
00:52:14,601 --> 00:52:16,701
That's how you make
multiplayer games at all.

1153
00:52:17,421 --> 00:52:18,651
It's completely different.

1154
00:52:18,651 --> 00:52:19,491
It's completely different.

1155
00:52:19,694 --> 00:52:22,934
when you're making a multiplayer
game, if I was to make an AI for a

1156
00:52:22,934 --> 00:52:27,473
multiplayer game, or when I have made
I for multiplayer games the focus is

1157
00:52:27,473 --> 00:52:29,453
not on like these series of hurdles.

1158
00:52:29,633 --> 00:52:30,508
It's about pushing her.

1159
00:52:31,408 --> 00:52:33,731
It's about testing her mastery
of different skillsets.

1160
00:52:34,481 --> 00:52:37,057
you could say that's kind of
similar to what you're doing in a

1161
00:52:37,057 --> 00:52:39,527
single player game, but it's the
testing and the mastery is no.

1162
00:52:39,527 --> 00:52:44,717
longer driven by some narrative is now
literally how fast can you achieve this?

1163
00:52:44,793 --> 00:52:48,153
it's, can you jump, can you walk,
can you run, can you do this?

1164
00:52:48,431 --> 00:52:51,481
the Asher, you can test somebody
mastery and then putting them

1165
00:52:51,481 --> 00:52:53,221
against a real player as quickly as

1166
00:52:53,221 --> 00:52:57,301
possible, ended observing what the
real players do against each other.

1167
00:52:57,481 --> 00:53:01,484
And that's what we call imitation learning
is now, we model in AI, off of the

1168
00:53:01,484 --> 00:53:03,584
imitation of what a real player would do.

1169
00:53:03,607 --> 00:53:04,147
John: I like that.

1170
00:53:04,177 --> 00:53:04,567
I like that.

1171
00:53:04,567 --> 00:53:04,747
Right.

1172
00:53:04,747 --> 00:53:08,227
Because my problem has always been that
for the solo player, who's trying to

1173
00:53:08,227 --> 00:53:13,777
solely get better by beating on bots
never, ever going to be a match for

1174
00:53:13,777 --> 00:53:15,337
somebody who's been playing other people.

1175
00:53:15,367 --> 00:53:18,157
But maybe goal is that.

1176
00:53:18,922 --> 00:53:23,402
Ben R: The AI that the stuff tends
to make it now beat 99.9, 7% of

1177
00:53:23,402 --> 00:53:24,512
the players or something like that.

1178
00:53:24,512 --> 00:53:26,942
Like it literally, it's an unbeatable AI.

1179
00:53:28,030 --> 00:53:30,668
came about after I assuming
you're familiar with the game go,

1180
00:53:30,802 --> 00:53:32,200
John: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1181
00:53:32,602 --> 00:53:33,292
Play it though.

1182
00:53:33,352 --> 00:53:34,402
But I know about.

1183
00:53:34,471 --> 00:53:36,571
Ben R: One of my mentors or
one, the people used to work at

1184
00:53:37,081 --> 00:53:39,665
LucasArts clan Hopkins,
he talks about a girl.

1185
00:53:39,665 --> 00:53:44,730
And about how there was this Japanese very
famous game of go where like you had the

1186
00:53:44,730 --> 00:53:49,110
traditional person who was very, you know,
like into the game ago, who like, was like

1187
00:53:49,110 --> 00:53:52,538
traditionally trained and he had upstart,
you have the new guy who was like, you

1188
00:53:52,538 --> 00:53:56,690
know, post world war two Americanized,
you know, Japanese go player.

1189
00:53:56,712 --> 00:53:58,434
And he did a very deceitful thing.

1190
00:53:58,914 --> 00:53:59,544
He met.

1191
00:54:00,369 --> 00:54:05,462
He, realized that at the end of the
day, when you sign like your, your

1192
00:54:05,488 --> 00:54:09,088
move or are you putting your move
into a envelope for the next day who

1193
00:54:09,098 --> 00:54:11,158
get games ago can last multiple days.

1194
00:54:11,158 --> 00:54:14,578
That's how in-depth go is instead of
chess where they're slapping the clock

1195
00:54:14,578 --> 00:54:17,738
every two seconds, you know they're
trying to be as fast as possible because

1196
00:54:17,738 --> 00:54:20,078
there is a finite move set in, in chess.

1197
00:54:20,146 --> 00:54:24,736
Neural girl has a much more probability
space, which is why they, it takes several

1198
00:54:24,736 --> 00:54:29,403
days, But but Clint Hocking, he talks
about, those match where there was a

1199
00:54:29,403 --> 00:54:33,333
very deceitful thing where somebody made
a move that was insignificant because

1200
00:54:33,333 --> 00:54:35,223
it gave him 24 hours to think about.

1201
00:54:35,223 --> 00:54:36,543
his actual next move.

1202
00:54:36,873 --> 00:54:40,084
And the go master was,
very offended by this.

1203
00:54:40,294 --> 00:54:44,117
He was like, you just,
you're not playing, but Yeah.

1204
00:54:44,117 --> 00:54:44,807
you're not playing for real.

1205
00:54:44,807 --> 00:54:46,067
you're gaming the system.

1206
00:54:46,547 --> 00:54:48,407
You literally met a gaming at this

1207
00:54:48,407 --> 00:54:48,647
point.

1208
00:54:48,647 --> 00:54:48,767
Like.

1209
00:54:49,833 --> 00:54:53,856
John: knew that if he gave him 24
hours to think about you know, that

1210
00:54:53,856 --> 00:54:57,894
he wanted to get to get to his like
space of something just kind of

1211
00:54:57,979 --> 00:54:58,099
Ben R: Yeah.

1212
00:54:58,112 --> 00:54:59,172
John: wasting that time.

1213
00:54:59,184 --> 00:54:59,384
Ben R: Yeah.

1214
00:54:59,384 --> 00:54:59,634
Yeah.

1215
00:54:59,664 --> 00:55:04,104
When Sam making the next logical
move, he made an illogical move

1216
00:55:04,134 --> 00:55:06,443
that gave him more time to think
about their next logical move.

1217
00:55:06,608 --> 00:55:10,278
made the, what would be if there was
infinite time, if there was not a time

1218
00:55:10,278 --> 00:55:13,142
between the last move of the match
and the next move of the match, the

1219
00:55:13,142 --> 00:55:17,072
next day, there wasn't 24 hours, then
he would have played differently.

1220
00:55:17,132 --> 00:55:19,472
If he was forced to on the
spot, make that decision.

1221
00:55:19,562 --> 00:55:23,192
He met a game, did, he was one of
the first example of metagame like

1222
00:55:23,192 --> 00:55:24,812
where he realized the rule set.

1223
00:55:24,812 --> 00:55:26,432
And he took himself
outside of the rule set.

1224
00:55:26,432 --> 00:55:29,820
Instead of playing as a player, Played
as a person who's trying to win.

1225
00:55:30,045 --> 00:55:30,615
John: Yeah.

1226
00:55:30,705 --> 00:55:31,455
Played a win.

1227
00:55:32,400 --> 00:55:35,043
Ben R: played play to
win outside of the play.

1228
00:55:35,113 --> 00:55:35,323
you know,

1229
00:55:35,498 --> 00:55:35,978
John: There you go.

1230
00:55:36,018 --> 00:55:38,448
I mean, that used to not
be a factor of the game.

1231
00:55:38,448 --> 00:55:38,628
Right?

1232
00:55:38,628 --> 00:55:41,028
If you break it down, the rule set,
you know, there's no thing that says

1233
00:55:41,028 --> 00:55:45,378
like, Hey, you know, humans get to
take a break after this much time.

1234
00:55:45,378 --> 00:55:45,558
Right?

1235
00:55:45,558 --> 00:55:46,848
Like that was not
something that was written.

1236
00:55:46,918 --> 00:55:49,948
Ben R: How was this something that when
the go people like it meant to go and they

1237
00:55:49,948 --> 00:55:53,288
were drawing with sticks and rocks on the
ground, which is how good was originally

1238
00:55:53,288 --> 00:55:55,868
created when a drawing with like sticks
and rocks on the ground, they were

1239
00:55:55,868 --> 00:55:59,172
playing go with a bunch of black rocks
and white rocks or whatever like that.

1240
00:55:59,172 --> 00:56:01,799
Wasn't something they considered that
was not something that was part of

1241
00:56:01,799 --> 00:56:06,359
the original rule set that person who,
like I say, like chess, chess person,

1242
00:56:06,359 --> 00:56:10,871
like didn't then think, well, if I give
people, infinite amount of time and

1243
00:56:10,931 --> 00:56:14,801
again, it comes back to the fact that
there is a much more finite rules space.

1244
00:56:14,801 --> 00:56:15,311
in chess.

1245
00:56:15,821 --> 00:56:20,077
there isn't go and go, there's, a
factorial greater of number of moves.

1246
00:56:20,197 --> 00:56:23,644
Because every time you put down a
rocket can cascade and he can like

1247
00:56:23,914 --> 00:56:26,344
capture things and like, and from it.

1248
00:56:26,344 --> 00:56:26,524
Yeah.

1249
00:56:26,524 --> 00:56:26,944
exactly.

1250
00:56:26,944 --> 00:56:30,864
So, so when 10 cent solved
The go AI basically.

1251
00:56:30,874 --> 00:56:32,374
It was the thing in like 2018.

1252
00:56:32,374 --> 00:56:34,099
It was like almost three
or four years ago now.

1253
00:56:34,133 --> 00:56:37,573
When they solved that, like when
or not Tencent explicitly, but

1254
00:56:37,573 --> 00:56:41,271
when, when they solved that within
that space, it was a huge thing.

1255
00:56:41,271 --> 00:56:42,261
It's called AlphaGo.

1256
00:56:42,310 --> 00:56:43,214
it was, It was, sort of

1257
00:56:43,214 --> 00:56:47,171
like, we went from like deep blue to
like they had you know so deep blue,

1258
00:56:47,171 --> 00:56:50,441
I don't even remember Casper off,
like, you know, back in the nineties,

1259
00:56:50,471 --> 00:56:50,711
like,

1260
00:56:50,711 --> 00:56:53,861
uh, you know, he almost
bought the Presidio.

1261
00:56:54,276 --> 00:56:55,176
John: Tampa, wait, Lugo.

1262
00:56:55,176 --> 00:56:57,276
When you tell him what the proceeding
you tell him about like bay area.

1263
00:56:57,835 --> 00:57:00,385
Ben R: They were trying to determine what,
what they were going to do with this park

1264
00:57:00,385 --> 00:57:05,748
space in Northern San Francisco and Louis
bid on it back in like the nineties.

1265
00:57:05,788 --> 00:57:07,888
John: And the grand masses
make that much money.

1266
00:57:08,633 --> 00:57:12,449
Ben R: I don't know where it's funny
it was coming from, but I think the,

1267
00:57:12,449 --> 00:57:16,479
the youth government decided that, that
the, the, the idea of using it as an

1268
00:57:16,479 --> 00:57:19,305
arts and entertainment center, instead
of like you know cutting out all the

1269
00:57:19,305 --> 00:57:22,724
trees and train to like some kind of
like residential place was, was more

1270
00:57:22,724 --> 00:57:24,750
beneficial to the city as a whole.

1271
00:57:24,789 --> 00:57:29,654
But yeah, the Kasparov actually bid
in and he was outbid or, or his, his

1272
00:57:29,654 --> 00:57:34,854
proposal was not as good as, as Lucas's,
which is why we have the Presidio up in

1273
00:57:35,144 --> 00:57:35,714
San Francisco

1274
00:57:35,999 --> 00:57:38,489
John: How far away are
you from the Presidio?

1275
00:57:39,524 --> 00:57:40,034
Ben R: blocks.

1276
00:57:40,034 --> 00:57:40,538
Like you know,

1277
00:57:41,408 --> 00:57:43,478
a stone throw a, I mean,
I can, I can take a bus.

1278
00:57:43,478 --> 00:57:44,618
I can be there in 12 minutes.

1279
00:57:44,718 --> 00:57:45,198
John: Nice.

1280
00:57:45,228 --> 00:57:45,678
Nice.

1281
00:57:45,768 --> 00:57:47,358
I like being near greenery, man.

1282
00:57:47,637 --> 00:57:51,048
Ben R: before this, I was working up
in Nevato and really miss the city.

1283
00:57:51,048 --> 00:57:53,808
And so I'm glad to be back in
it, like it was, a little bit

1284
00:57:53,838 --> 00:57:55,638
disconnected in the north.

1285
00:57:56,222 --> 00:57:58,471
But like I'm, I'm really
happy to be back in the city.

1286
00:57:58,641 --> 00:57:59,721
John: I got to ask you, right.

1287
00:57:59,721 --> 00:58:03,081
Activision's in the news major
purchase by Microsoft, right?

1288
00:58:03,081 --> 00:58:06,051
Like almost $70 billion
to buy the whole thing.

1289
00:58:06,681 --> 00:58:09,951
everybody has this speculation
as to the winds and the IPS, but

1290
00:58:09,951 --> 00:58:11,331
you can't argue the portfolio.

1291
00:58:11,721 --> 00:58:14,091
Ben R: We'll also be also
birds with Zynga as well.

1292
00:58:14,091 --> 00:58:14,381
You

1293
00:58:14,421 --> 00:58:15,471
heard that part, right?

1294
00:58:16,031 --> 00:58:16,631
John: I'll hold on.

1295
00:58:16,661 --> 00:58:18,521
Zynga was take two.

1296
00:58:19,191 --> 00:58:19,491
Ben R: Bye.

1297
00:58:19,521 --> 00:58:23,220
Oh, no tuning to gain, to gain capitalism
you know to gain gaps, leads and

1298
00:58:23,400 --> 00:58:23,730
John: Yeah.

1299
00:58:24,390 --> 00:58:24,990
Ben R: activation.

1300
00:58:24,990 --> 00:58:25,230
Yeah.

1301
00:58:25,660 --> 00:58:26,820
I, I call it active.

1302
00:58:27,030 --> 00:58:29,490
John: Major purchases all like
in the same time window, right?

1303
00:58:29,490 --> 00:58:30,960
Like big ass acquisitions for

1304
00:58:31,075 --> 00:58:32,925
Ben R: it's in the fiscal year.

1305
00:58:32,925 --> 00:58:35,235
It's like when these kinds of things
come out, like they've been working

1306
00:58:35,235 --> 00:58:38,745
on this the same way that, you know,
they could have told us a year ahead

1307
00:58:38,745 --> 00:58:41,475
of time when they were going to shut
down because arts, because the Disney

1308
00:58:41,569 --> 00:58:45,319
deal was going through, like they could
have told us they instead, Kathleen

1309
00:58:45,319 --> 00:58:49,362
Kennedy came down and tap Jeff Boris, my
producer on the shoulder and said by the

1310
00:58:49,362 --> 00:58:51,582
way, you can't release this game today.

1311
00:58:51,582 --> 00:58:56,198
Like like it was literally, we were,
we were live for an Xbox live or we

1312
00:58:56,198 --> 00:59:00,398
were ready to like pull the trigger
on Xbox live beta with 10,000 people.

1313
00:59:00,698 --> 00:59:04,552
They some people data mined and
they found the cover on the store.

1314
00:59:04,720 --> 00:59:05,672
we were ready to go.

1315
00:59:05,672 --> 00:59:09,567
Like sometimes production and
anybody who doesn't understand that

1316
00:59:09,567 --> 00:59:11,197
the games are driven by marketing.

1317
00:59:11,733 --> 00:59:15,439
Slap in the face for you, you know,
bucket of cold water, the reason why

1318
00:59:15,439 --> 00:59:18,559
most game companies feel today is not
because they don't have good games.

1319
00:59:18,859 --> 00:59:21,229
It's because they don't have
good marketing and marketing.

1320
00:59:21,319 --> 00:59:25,429
And this is the reason why, why zinger the
good-bye out companies is the reason why,

1321
00:59:25,512 --> 00:59:30,012
they could, you know, recreate games is
because marketing is 60% of your budget.

1322
00:59:30,143 --> 00:59:30,713
if you're going to

1323
00:59:30,863 --> 00:59:35,273
average and being the next day,
Bola, you know, going off and

1324
00:59:35,273 --> 00:59:37,253
make your own game studio like.

1325
00:59:38,468 --> 00:59:38,728
Yeah.

1326
00:59:38,728 --> 00:59:39,008
yeah.

1327
00:59:39,048 --> 00:59:39,638
Next polio.

1328
00:59:39,698 --> 00:59:40,028
Yeah.

1329
00:59:40,118 --> 00:59:40,878
Shout out to Danny.

1330
00:59:41,233 --> 00:59:43,963
doesn't every full cell graduate,
like go out and just start throwing

1331
00:59:43,963 --> 00:59:48,065
game company is because it doesn't
matter like the production costs, what

1332
00:59:48,065 --> 00:59:50,735
matters is, is new, new user funnel.

1333
00:59:51,095 --> 00:59:53,875
And this is, this is what we, figured
out on discord and  is because it's

1334
00:59:53,875 --> 00:59:57,459
not about making a great product and
not, not about making a great game.

1335
00:59:57,459 --> 00:59:59,739
It's not making about
great, a great platform.

1336
00:59:59,979 --> 01:00:00,879
None of that matters.

1337
01:00:00,909 --> 01:00:05,362
If You do not have marketing the
majority of your budget, like 60% of

1338
01:00:05,362 --> 01:00:08,444
your budget, if you're going to make
game title should be allocated towards

1339
01:00:08,444 --> 01:00:13,178
marketing because can buy clicks, you
can buy, like she can do viral marketing.

1340
01:00:13,206 --> 01:00:14,196
John: you can buy a streamer.

1341
01:00:14,581 --> 01:00:18,731
Ben R: You can do everything you can like
to make a great game, but nobody plays it.

1342
01:00:19,721 --> 01:00:20,651
Is that a great game?

1343
01:00:20,979 --> 01:00:22,029
John: That's a good point, man.

1344
01:00:22,059 --> 01:00:23,049
Nobody knows about it, right?

1345
01:00:23,049 --> 01:00:25,679
Like, I mean, you have these
indie breakout hits, right?

1346
01:00:25,679 --> 01:00:29,511
That over time, word spreads, word
of mouth, and that's how they come

1347
01:00:29,511 --> 01:00:33,211
up without zero marketing, but
it's rare and far between, right?

1348
01:00:33,211 --> 01:00:37,561
that's why these publisher deals
exist as shitty or much as you want

1349
01:00:37,561 --> 01:00:38,941
to avoid them or do your own thing.

1350
01:00:39,391 --> 01:00:40,771
They help get the word out.

1351
01:00:40,771 --> 01:00:41,041
Right.

1352
01:00:41,041 --> 01:00:45,211
They get you on these storefront
pages, they're in their catalog.

1353
01:00:45,241 --> 01:00:45,582
Right.

1354
01:00:46,012 --> 01:00:47,775
Ben R: ask me, you know,
like you have good ideas.

1355
01:00:47,805 --> 01:00:49,920
Like one, you try to make her own venture.

1356
01:00:49,920 --> 01:00:50,940
And I, I have

1357
01:00:51,105 --> 01:00:52,545
John: it wouldn't surprise me, man.

1358
01:00:52,660 --> 01:00:54,880
Ben R: I've started a dozen
companies over the past 10 years.

1359
01:00:54,880 --> 01:00:56,890
Like my first company ever
was the most successful.

1360
01:00:56,890 --> 01:01:00,010
When I was 16, I made called
magic city, web design.

1361
01:01:00,040 --> 01:01:05,349
I made websites for a mentally disabled
groups not groups themselves, but

1362
01:01:05,349 --> 01:01:06,759
for people who are advocates of them.

1363
01:01:06,939 --> 01:01:09,969
So the things like the national
lines, familial, or the Alabama

1364
01:01:09,969 --> 01:01:14,255
family trust, like I was working with,
nonprofits in the area, like, and this

1365
01:01:14,255 --> 01:01:15,965
is during the early two thousands.

1366
01:01:15,965 --> 01:01:18,455
So while people were still
figuring out what the web was like,

1367
01:01:18,570 --> 01:01:19,830
John: Yeah, timing.

1368
01:01:19,830 --> 01:01:20,190
Timing.

1369
01:01:20,370 --> 01:01:22,080
Must've been a big part of that for sure.

1370
01:01:22,255 --> 01:01:23,185
Ben R: it was a big part of that.

1371
01:01:23,425 --> 01:01:25,405
I mean, it helped pay
for my college education.

1372
01:01:25,495 --> 01:01:28,075
I'm like, that's how I help.

1373
01:01:28,145 --> 01:01:32,245
I mean, thank you to my grandparents and
my parents for helping with that as well.

1374
01:01:32,437 --> 01:01:35,859
part of my college funding actually came
from, the profits, from that venture.

1375
01:01:36,249 --> 01:01:39,465
But, you know, I made probably
at least a dozen companies

1376
01:01:39,465 --> 01:01:40,875
over the past several years.

1377
01:01:40,888 --> 01:01:45,107
But the, important thing is, is, you
have to have not just a product and that

1378
01:01:45,107 --> 01:01:46,697
has to not just be a marketable product.

1379
01:01:46,697 --> 01:01:47,957
There has to be a market for it.

1380
01:01:48,227 --> 01:01:49,397
There has to, you have to know what

1381
01:01:49,397 --> 01:01:49,547
you're

1382
01:01:49,547 --> 01:01:49,997
targeting.

1383
01:01:50,252 --> 01:01:50,612
John: this thing.

1384
01:01:50,612 --> 01:01:51,752
Who's going to be buying this thing

1385
01:01:52,097 --> 01:01:52,307
Ben R: Yeah.

1386
01:01:52,307 --> 01:01:53,267
Who's going to be playing this thing.

1387
01:01:53,267 --> 01:01:54,287
Who's gonna be buying this thing

1388
01:01:54,317 --> 01:01:56,117
Like when, when, when, you know,

1389
01:01:56,192 --> 01:01:56,782
John: often, right?

1390
01:01:56,782 --> 01:01:57,802
Like it's rare

1391
01:01:58,097 --> 01:02:00,677
Ben R: one of my favorite parts is
when, when dollars come to donuts,

1392
01:02:01,997 --> 01:02:03,974
you know, it's a Southern phrase.

1393
01:02:03,974 --> 01:02:05,564
Or maybe it's just something
I heard over the years,

1394
01:02:05,853 --> 01:02:06,663
John: no repeat that, man.

1395
01:02:06,663 --> 01:02:07,383
I haven't heard that one.

1396
01:02:07,708 --> 01:02:08,068
Ben R: dollars.

1397
01:02:08,903 --> 01:02:10,178
John: what does that break down to?

1398
01:02:10,178 --> 01:02:12,188
Ben R: how do you get fed
at the end of the day?

1399
01:02:12,818 --> 01:02:13,528
John: Uh,

1400
01:02:13,658 --> 01:02:14,918
Ben R: you making money with your game?

1401
01:02:14,948 --> 01:02:15,488
Are you,

1402
01:02:15,608 --> 01:02:15,908
John: are you

1403
01:02:15,908 --> 01:02:17,371
eating, are you eating,

1404
01:02:17,911 --> 01:02:18,091
Ben R: yeah.

1405
01:02:18,144 --> 01:02:18,954
are you eating.

1406
01:02:18,984 --> 01:02:22,904
like, when shit hits the road or when
like, you know, road meets the pavement

1407
01:02:22,904 --> 01:02:25,514
or wherever you want to call it, there's
a lot of turn of phrases out there.

1408
01:02:25,824 --> 01:02:28,374
I've seen very few people
who've struck out on their own.

1409
01:02:28,584 --> 01:02:31,580
One of the people I really look
up to again, I got to give a

1410
01:02:31,580 --> 01:02:33,202
big shout out to Ken Hudson.

1411
01:02:33,202 --> 01:02:35,230
he was guy back in the day.

1412
01:02:35,339 --> 01:02:37,049
John: Yo, I'm going to
link up with him, man.

1413
01:02:37,079 --> 01:02:37,799
I'm linking up with him.

1414
01:02:37,799 --> 01:02:39,899
He's going to be on the
podcast, not too long from

1415
01:02:40,224 --> 01:02:41,994
Ben R: I would love to hear that podcast.

1416
01:02:42,024 --> 01:02:43,614
Please, please bring him on the show.

1417
01:02:43,704 --> 01:02:44,244
Please bring him up.

1418
01:02:44,797 --> 01:02:48,379
but no he's, he's one of the few people
that, that struck out like doing his own

1419
01:02:48,379 --> 01:02:52,046
venture, but the reason why I felt like he
was so successful and I think he actually

1420
01:02:52,046 --> 01:02:54,506
won an academy award for one of his

1421
01:02:54,506 --> 01:02:54,836
things.

1422
01:02:54,873 --> 01:02:58,308
he went back to work with, Clint
on, watch out legions, like

1423
01:02:58,338 --> 01:02:59,857
either throw up in in Toronto

1424
01:03:00,067 --> 01:03:00,697
in that area.

1425
01:03:00,957 --> 01:03:03,957
John: I think he's in this new spot
called brass line entertainment,

1426
01:03:03,957 --> 01:03:05,217
but I think he's out of Toronto.

1427
01:03:05,329 --> 01:03:05,749
Ben R: yeah.

1428
01:03:05,779 --> 01:03:06,469
After Toronto.

1429
01:03:06,515 --> 01:03:08,495
but he was one of the few people
that I've, I've seen really

1430
01:03:08,765 --> 01:03:10,175
strike it out on a new venture.

1431
01:03:10,175 --> 01:03:12,605
Like, you know, go, go
stake a claim somewhere.

1432
01:03:13,535 --> 01:03:13,715
Yeah.

1433
01:03:13,745 --> 01:03:14,463
Break from the mold.

1434
01:03:14,521 --> 01:03:19,244
And you're out there and you know,
just took a simple idea or like

1435
01:03:19,244 --> 01:03:22,604
a core, what we used to call it
a full-scale look of the nugget,

1436
01:03:22,724 --> 01:03:25,164
like, Yeah.

1437
01:03:25,194 --> 01:03:26,144
what's your nugget, like?

1438
01:03:26,144 --> 01:03:27,654
You know, what is your core idea?

1439
01:03:27,654 --> 01:03:32,930
He took it, he marketed it, he got the
whole package downright and like, you

1440
01:03:32,930 --> 01:03:35,620
know, it's, it's something that like,
you know, I look towards like a, you

1441
01:03:35,620 --> 01:03:39,463
know, maybe one time during the future,
but The only, the only way I would

1442
01:03:39,463 --> 01:03:43,493
do another product or I strike out on
my own is if I had a platform first

1443
01:03:43,493 --> 01:03:47,393
and like, I'm going, like the game
would be a product of the platform.

1444
01:03:48,247 --> 01:03:48,517
John: Hell.

1445
01:03:48,517 --> 01:03:48,907
Yeah.

1446
01:03:49,303 --> 01:03:53,539
Ben R: I, believe in platforms like, you
know when I was working with Jason Citron

1447
01:03:53,549 --> 01:03:56,709
at discord, he's like, there's three
major things you got to think about when

1448
01:03:56,709 --> 01:03:59,659
you're starting a company or when you're
starting a, a pro product or whatever.

1449
01:03:59,659 --> 01:04:01,383
It's people product process.

1450
01:04:01,799 --> 01:04:05,159
are my last game, like, I can't talk
too much about it cause you know

1451
01:04:05,183 --> 01:04:08,903
it was never released, but we were
trying to do too many things at once.

1452
01:04:09,097 --> 01:04:13,167
we had a new team, we had a new product,
we had a new process and, if you want to

1453
01:04:13,167 --> 01:04:18,020
do all three at the same time, like it's
gonna take a long time develop each one,

1454
01:04:18,440 --> 01:04:21,200
like longer than a normal game dev cycle.

1455
01:04:21,965 --> 01:04:25,377
If you're, if you're gonna make
something new, you should focus on

1456
01:04:25,377 --> 01:04:30,717
one vector and of those three, you're
going to have a new team then fine.

1457
01:04:30,747 --> 01:04:34,735
If you want to make a sequel to, you know,
the greatest game of all time something

1458
01:04:34,735 --> 01:04:37,705
like, you know, you want to make the next
league of legends or something like, you

1459
01:04:37,705 --> 01:04:42,445
know, you're gonna make legal legends
who were doted to ironically, like you

1460
01:04:42,445 --> 01:04:47,170
have to have a understood process and
understood product, which they did.

1461
01:04:47,650 --> 01:04:49,510
And then you have to have new people.

1462
01:04:49,720 --> 01:04:52,900
Like you can't, you can't do
all three at the same time only.

1463
01:04:52,900 --> 01:04:54,550
It's a, it's a good, fast, cheap,

1464
01:04:55,350 --> 01:04:55,700
John: Yeah.

1465
01:04:55,700 --> 01:04:56,040
Yeah, yeah.

1466
01:04:56,070 --> 01:04:56,430
Damn man.

1467
01:04:56,460 --> 01:05:00,407
You just broke down, the riot games,
success story right there, man.

1468
01:05:00,407 --> 01:05:00,467
I

1469
01:05:00,607 --> 01:05:00,787
Ben R: Yeah.

1470
01:05:00,827 --> 01:05:01,397
John: thought about that.

1471
01:05:01,397 --> 01:05:01,547
Right.

1472
01:05:01,547 --> 01:05:06,437
Like, Hey, they just kinda looked at
something that was proven and existed and

1473
01:05:06,437 --> 01:05:10,967
they didn't have to kind of reinvent it so
that they can then build out their team.

1474
01:05:11,087 --> 01:05:11,297
Right.

1475
01:05:11,337 --> 01:05:11,517
Ben R: Yeah.

1476
01:05:11,837 --> 01:05:14,627
John: kind of facilitated building
out their process and tools.

1477
01:05:14,627 --> 01:05:15,047
And then

1478
01:05:15,587 --> 01:05:18,287
Ben R: They already have a pretty well
understood and established process.

1479
01:05:18,287 --> 01:05:20,957
Like I think at least from my
understanding, they had a tool set.

1480
01:05:20,957 --> 01:05:22,337
They had an engine, they built the engine.

1481
01:05:22,337 --> 01:05:23,807
Like but also understood their market.

1482
01:05:23,908 --> 01:05:26,178
you know what the greatest thing
about, about league of legends is

1483
01:05:26,508 --> 01:05:27,168
John: what's that.

1484
01:05:27,318 --> 01:05:28,458
Ben R: it runs on any machine.

1485
01:05:28,619 --> 01:05:29,809
John: Yeah.

1486
01:05:30,363 --> 01:05:33,408
Ben R: if you're a Brazil player,
if you're a white going away,

1487
01:05:33,648 --> 01:05:36,651
like if you're playing a mortar,
Kaiser, like, you know, you, you can

1488
01:05:36,651 --> 01:05:38,649
still, you can still enjoy product.

1489
01:05:38,845 --> 01:05:39,325
John: Hell.

1490
01:05:39,385 --> 01:05:39,925
Yeah.

1491
01:05:40,299 --> 01:05:41,709
Ben R: An educator being an instructor.

1492
01:05:41,709 --> 01:05:42,819
Like I think about things.

1493
01:05:42,819 --> 01:05:44,389
I try to break it down for people.

1494
01:05:44,389 --> 01:05:49,035
I hope the message gets across
because I am my own thought process

1495
01:05:49,035 --> 01:05:50,445
and not everybody thinks the same.

1496
01:05:50,445 --> 01:05:53,205
Like I don't, I don't like everybody
to have the same experiences,

1497
01:05:53,205 --> 01:05:56,348
like as well, there's a difference
between intelligence and wisdom.

1498
01:05:56,715 --> 01:05:59,546
Lots of people can be intelligent
have a heightened score.

1499
01:05:59,846 --> 01:06:01,166
Like if you want to get down to D and D

1500
01:06:01,166 --> 01:06:05,126
terms, like, you know, like why do
clerics have high whiz in low end?

1501
01:06:05,156 --> 01:06:08,726
And why do, sourcer wizards have
high end low is, is because.

1502
01:06:08,782 --> 01:06:11,332
I think there are too many
wizards and sorcerers.

1503
01:06:11,532 --> 01:06:15,912
again, that industry, like there are
people that have really smart brain,

1504
01:06:15,942 --> 01:06:18,051
but they don't stop and smell the roses.

1505
01:06:18,051 --> 01:06:19,311
they don't see the full picture.

1506
01:06:19,425 --> 01:06:23,230
in the Meyers-Briggs terms like,
you know, you can be a person that

1507
01:06:23,230 --> 01:06:26,757
is, thinking or feeling but you can
also be a person that is observant

1508
01:06:26,803 --> 01:06:27,553
John: perceiver.

1509
01:06:27,753 --> 01:06:32,515
Ben R: NFE or ENTP, like early feel or
my two Myers-Briggs like they, do you

1510
01:06:32,515 --> 01:06:34,525
see the trees or do you see the forest?

1511
01:06:35,381 --> 01:06:39,143
you get caught up on this sensory and,
but, or do you see, are you perceptive?

1512
01:06:39,353 --> 01:06:41,123
Do you see the bigger picture?

1513
01:06:41,307 --> 01:06:45,563
the leaders that I look to and the
people that mentors to me are people

1514
01:06:45,573 --> 01:06:47,363
that they can take that step back.

1515
01:06:48,173 --> 01:06:50,333
Hey, let's not talk about a game.

1516
01:06:50,333 --> 01:06:52,163
Let's talk about the game industry.

1517
01:06:52,163 --> 01:06:55,257
and that's why I love what you're
doing here with this podcast.

1518
01:06:55,257 --> 01:06:56,817
you're taking people out of the moment.

1519
01:06:56,817 --> 01:06:57,776
You're saying, okay.

1520
01:06:57,886 --> 01:07:01,156
Let's stop thinking about like when
the next milestone is what your next

1521
01:07:01,156 --> 01:07:02,981
task what's your next leg deadline.

1522
01:07:03,020 --> 01:07:06,392
And you, you say to people, Hey, let's,
let's talk about this holistically.

1523
01:07:06,544 --> 01:07:07,954
let's think about this for a second.

1524
01:07:08,101 --> 01:07:09,091
why do we make games?

1525
01:07:09,091 --> 01:07:11,671
And that's what dream
week was all about for me?

1526
01:07:11,739 --> 01:07:16,629
when I first proposed the idea to, to
K dream week was, you know, something

1527
01:07:16,629 --> 01:07:20,062
that it's about the, why not the
what, it's not, what are we making?

1528
01:07:20,062 --> 01:07:22,012
It's like, why are we making
it in the first place?

1529
01:07:22,186 --> 01:07:25,546
And I think you can do this
with any industry would remove,

1530
01:07:25,546 --> 01:07:27,151
was it was, it was five days.

1531
01:07:27,151 --> 01:07:30,301
It was, it was a full work week where,
you know, I purchased the company.

1532
01:07:30,301 --> 01:07:34,498
I said, Hey, can you give us all
your resources and all of our, all

1533
01:07:34,498 --> 01:07:39,286
of your, you know, multi-billion
dollar, you know access to, all

1534
01:07:39,286 --> 01:07:40,366
the things that you have access to.

1535
01:07:40,396 --> 01:07:41,416
Can we take all your tools?

1536
01:07:41,429 --> 01:07:44,699
All of the things that we normally
have access to, but we focus on a

1537
01:07:44,699 --> 01:07:47,029
particular product and can we just
let people just make whatever they.

1538
01:07:47,756 --> 01:07:50,426
can a person take a step back
and they not make what they want.

1539
01:07:50,426 --> 01:07:52,346
Can they write about like what they want?

1540
01:07:52,346 --> 01:07:54,176
Like we had, we had a person
that did nothing but just

1541
01:07:54,176 --> 01:07:55,556
journal for the entire week.

1542
01:07:55,556 --> 01:07:57,596
Like they just wrote about games.

1543
01:07:57,596 --> 01:08:02,550
Like it's about engagement and dream
week is also about how you, as a user,

1544
01:08:02,550 --> 01:08:05,670
want to engage, it's not a, not deadline.

1545
01:08:05,670 --> 01:08:06,600
It's not a timeline.

1546
01:08:06,600 --> 01:08:10,500
It's not like some people do engage better
based on deadlines or timelines, and some

1547
01:08:10,500 --> 01:08:11,970
people want to compete with each other.

1548
01:08:12,180 --> 01:08:16,357
So we did elect a panel of judges
like from, every demographic

1549
01:08:16,387 --> 01:08:19,592
and sexual background and,
you know, race and everything.

1550
01:08:19,592 --> 01:08:23,321
Like in geographic background, we, we
made a very diverse panel of judges.

1551
01:08:23,372 --> 01:08:25,874
But, goal was to make sure that.

1552
01:08:25,913 --> 01:08:29,744
everybody felt recognized that everybody
felt like they were, doing something

1553
01:08:29,744 --> 01:08:34,716
that was worthy and just give them
the, full weight of a corporation

1554
01:08:35,016 --> 01:08:36,876
to, to make their dreams come true.

1555
01:08:37,060 --> 01:08:37,870
John: That's epic, man.

1556
01:08:37,870 --> 01:08:40,660
I love because the fact, you know,
you have an international team, right?

1557
01:08:40,660 --> 01:08:42,130
Like spread out all over the world.

1558
01:08:42,130 --> 01:08:43,450
So diversity.

1559
01:08:43,544 --> 01:08:45,918
Ben R: I'm up all hours of
the night interfacing with

1560
01:08:45,979 --> 01:08:47,179
you know, people in the UK.

1561
01:08:47,179 --> 01:08:49,681
We have we have assume Britain, we
have a studio in the Czech Republic.

1562
01:08:49,681 --> 01:08:51,721
We have our actually multiple
students in the Czech Republic.

1563
01:08:51,875 --> 01:08:54,089
we have outsourcers that
we work with in China.

1564
01:08:54,399 --> 01:08:55,189
I don't get much sleep.

1565
01:08:56,759 --> 01:08:57,589
I work a lot.

1566
01:08:57,589 --> 01:09:01,244
And but, when you love what you do, you
never worked another day in your life.

1567
01:09:01,244 --> 01:09:02,634
That was something my dad taught me.

1568
01:09:02,680 --> 01:09:07,342
That's something, you know, I hold
true to my, my story is, is you know,

1569
01:09:07,419 --> 01:09:12,129
when you love, when you genuinely enjoy
what you're doing and like, I felt this

1570
01:09:12,129 --> 01:09:13,809
way, working with, with Dave as well.

1571
01:09:14,169 --> 01:09:16,029
It's like, it's not,
it's not a job anymore.

1572
01:09:16,119 --> 01:09:18,219
It's really, now it's a passion.

1573
01:09:18,272 --> 01:09:19,052
it's a drive.

1574
01:09:19,082 --> 01:09:22,484
It's something that, is a defining
characteristic, to look background, I

1575
01:09:22,484 --> 01:09:27,234
started up, like, it's just, it just,
it just became another stat of mine.

1576
01:09:27,270 --> 01:09:28,371
But you know, okay.

1577
01:09:28,401 --> 01:09:30,951
Why I leveled up my game dev stats today?

1578
01:09:31,149 --> 01:09:31,479
John: Hell.

1579
01:09:31,479 --> 01:09:32,029
Yeah, dude.

1580
01:09:32,029 --> 01:09:35,179
I love taking the time to
link up, kick it with you.

1581
01:09:35,251 --> 01:09:40,374
Dream week, I mean, just seems like
something that creatives need, right?

1582
01:09:40,374 --> 01:09:41,134
Like we kind of.

1583
01:09:41,284 --> 01:09:42,364
Ben R: No, not just creative.

1584
01:09:42,394 --> 01:09:44,074
It's something that
everybody's I was talking

1585
01:09:44,099 --> 01:09:45,719
John: human people, people,

1586
01:09:45,959 --> 01:09:46,229
people

1587
01:09:46,229 --> 01:09:46,529
need

1588
01:09:46,804 --> 01:09:46,984
Ben R: like

1589
01:09:47,104 --> 01:09:47,754
I,

1590
01:09:48,359 --> 01:09:52,319
John: people in, in marketing, people,
in HR, people in, in, in services,

1591
01:09:52,334 --> 01:09:55,104
Ben R: thing is, is you don't
have to do your normal job.

1592
01:09:55,158 --> 01:09:56,418
One of the coolest projects.

1593
01:09:56,433 --> 01:10:00,125
so dream week was actually inspired or,
appropriated is probably the better word.

1594
01:10:00,125 --> 01:10:03,574
Like from Lucas arts, like
closure and back in 2009.

1595
01:10:03,574 --> 01:10:07,054
And I still have, I probably
displayed the ribbon on my wall.

1596
01:10:07,324 --> 01:10:09,814
I got, I got best knockoff.

1597
01:10:12,624 --> 01:10:14,494
Some people would take that offensively.

1598
01:10:15,199 --> 01:10:16,159
John: you copy something.

1599
01:10:16,624 --> 01:10:20,446
Ben R: What, like well, what
we had made a 1942 clone

1600
01:10:20,446 --> 01:10:23,446
John: 1942 is like vertical
top-down plane scrolling up,

1601
01:10:23,446 --> 01:10:26,866
shoots a bullet shooter thing.

1602
01:10:27,171 --> 01:10:27,621
Ben R: Exactly.

1603
01:10:27,621 --> 01:10:27,981
Yeah.

1604
01:10:28,461 --> 01:10:31,541
There's, there's lots of
Japanese, like, you know, bullets,

1605
01:10:31,541 --> 01:10:32,661
shooter kind of games out there.

1606
01:10:32,764 --> 01:10:33,064
Well, Yeah.

1607
01:10:33,074 --> 01:10:37,360
we thank you for, for giving some context
for your listeners, We at four people

1608
01:10:37,400 --> 01:10:41,622
we had we and myself we had a producer,
we had a, you know, a audio guy and we

1609
01:10:41,622 --> 01:10:43,359
had an animator shout out to can too.

1610
01:10:43,395 --> 01:10:44,985
But we didn't have a Mahler.

1611
01:10:45,105 --> 01:10:47,145
We didn't have a person that
can make models for a game.

1612
01:10:47,345 --> 01:10:49,665
so again, designing within constraints,

1613
01:10:49,665 --> 01:10:50,505
designed with Katrina.

1614
01:10:50,745 --> 01:10:53,489
What we did is we took up, we took
a camera, like back in the day

1615
01:10:53,489 --> 01:10:55,700
when you had like, you know, like
handheld cameras, like number, it

1616
01:10:55,700 --> 01:10:57,320
was a phone with an actual camera.

1617
01:10:57,680 --> 01:11:01,807
I can, we, we took a top-down
pictures  each of the,

1618
01:11:01,807 --> 01:11:03,447
stuffed animals in the office.

1619
01:11:03,917 --> 01:11:06,847
And then the animals beginning,
the characters  would tilt

1620
01:11:06,847 --> 01:11:08,377
them slightly 45 degrees.

1621
01:11:08,377 --> 01:11:12,637
We take a picture like, it's the way
you do stop motion, like way as the

1622
01:11:12,637 --> 01:11:14,150
way, you know, robot chicken was made.

1623
01:11:14,150 --> 01:11:15,280
Like you do stop motion.

1624
01:11:15,280 --> 01:11:17,770
Like, and so all we did
is we, we hit frames

1625
01:11:18,580 --> 01:11:19,120
John: Yes.

1626
01:11:19,150 --> 01:11:20,650
And that's the meaning of banking.

1627
01:11:20,910 --> 01:11:21,150
Ben R: Yeah.

1628
01:11:21,150 --> 01:11:24,360
If you're turning begging
you, you turn her left.

1629
01:11:24,370 --> 01:11:24,600
Right.

1630
01:11:24,649 --> 01:11:28,163
the gameplay, except for the, final
unicorn boss battle that I'd made.

1631
01:11:28,373 --> 01:11:31,493
I stayed 72 hours over the
weekend in order to get that

1632
01:11:31,493 --> 01:11:32,363
boss battle line, because

1633
01:11:32,473 --> 01:11:34,726
John: what was the
timeframe for a dream week?

1634
01:11:34,726 --> 01:11:36,518
Was it a week literally like, seven days.

1635
01:11:37,116 --> 01:11:37,866
Ben R: it was, seven days.

1636
01:11:37,866 --> 01:11:41,425
but, one of the things that we, we
settled on, like talking to HR and like

1637
01:11:41,455 --> 01:11:45,885
in working with the international team,
we're very big on corporate culture

1638
01:11:45,885 --> 01:11:48,915
and we don't want to ask people to
work outside of normal working hours.

1639
01:11:48,915 --> 01:11:51,105
So we did not want to
extend it over the weekend.

1640
01:11:51,105 --> 01:11:54,465
We did not want to have people coming
in on Saturday or Sunday working on it.

1641
01:11:54,465 --> 01:11:57,315
So, so we, we, we stuck to
five days, like a normal,

1642
01:11:57,315 --> 01:11:58,008
like, eight hours.

1643
01:11:58,350 --> 01:12:02,331
John: start Monday, submit Friday
night or start Monday review Monday.

1644
01:12:02,428 --> 01:12:04,358
Ben R: cause we had to deal
with the Czech Republic.

1645
01:12:04,358 --> 01:12:06,128
So the Czech Republic is nine hours ahead.

1646
01:12:06,158 --> 01:12:07,967
So they're They're GMT plus one.

1647
01:12:08,141 --> 01:12:10,151
we started on their
beginning of their Workday.

1648
01:12:11,071 --> 01:12:13,631
We ended up on the end
of the Workday on Friday.

1649
01:12:13,631 --> 01:12:16,942
So, Yeah, I think, I think it
was, I don't remember that.

1650
01:12:17,002 --> 01:12:20,542
Well, that's another thing about Jamie
is that people submitted shit late.

1651
01:12:20,602 --> 01:12:21,472
Like I didn't care.

1652
01:12:21,472 --> 01:12:21,652
Like

1653
01:12:22,602 --> 01:12:24,162
John: We don't give a
shit about deadlines.

1654
01:12:25,222 --> 01:12:28,552
Ben R: we, we do for people who
want deadlines, we gave them a day.

1655
01:12:29,272 --> 01:12:30,442
For people who don't want their lines.

1656
01:12:30,545 --> 01:12:32,435
there were three vectors
of dream week, right?

1657
01:12:32,735 --> 01:12:35,985
There were, there were
people who wanted to compete.

1658
01:12:35,985 --> 01:12:39,665
And even within that, there were people
that wanted to have a pre-formed team

1659
01:12:39,875 --> 01:12:41,655
and people that wanted to be match made.

1660
01:12:41,655 --> 01:12:43,625
So I, I actually made two cues.

1661
01:12:43,655 --> 01:12:47,465
Like if you have a pre-made Q team, the
same way that we do matchmaking in a game,

1662
01:12:47,470 --> 01:12:48,100
John: Yeah.

1663
01:12:48,485 --> 01:12:51,245
Ben R: so they don't get judged,
they don't get judged by the same

1664
01:12:51,455 --> 01:12:53,285
categories, as the people who were solved

1665
01:12:53,285 --> 01:12:55,865
you, they have a whole
different judging category.

1666
01:12:56,105 --> 01:12:57,605
Like I I'm, I'm going to write a

1667
01:12:57,605 --> 01:12:58,115
blog post.

1668
01:12:58,710 --> 01:13:00,180
John: that's super equitable, right?

1669
01:13:00,180 --> 01:13:04,590
Like, because there's definitely
to like having rapport and knowing

1670
01:13:04,590 --> 01:13:07,320
each other versus people like
having to get to know each other,

1671
01:13:07,320 --> 01:13:08,550
just to start working together.

1672
01:13:08,990 --> 01:13:09,290
Ben R: Yeah.

1673
01:13:09,350 --> 01:13:09,560
Yeah.

1674
01:13:09,590 --> 01:13:13,009
no, the people that were working
together for the first time you

1675
01:13:13,009 --> 01:13:15,199
know, we had the match made masters.

1676
01:13:15,439 --> 01:13:20,089
We had the, the, the best indie solo,
like we add like, you know, different

1677
01:13:20,089 --> 01:13:26,316
awards that we gave to each group based
on what their were and how they, how

1678
01:13:26,316 --> 01:13:29,293
they worked within those constraints
cause it's not, it's not fair.

1679
01:13:29,293 --> 01:13:32,196
Like, so some of the pre-made teams
had been working for a month ahead

1680
01:13:32,196 --> 01:13:35,016
of time, even before we announced,
cause they already had a team,

1681
01:13:35,196 --> 01:13:36,996
they were already working on a rat.

1682
01:13:36,996 --> 01:13:40,056
Catcher was one of the names of the
games where you have to catch a rat

1683
01:13:40,056 --> 01:13:43,116
as a, as a cat, there were two, two
separate teams in the Czech Republic.

1684
01:13:43,146 --> 01:13:46,056
They were already working on this for a
month ahead of time and it wasn't fair

1685
01:13:46,056 --> 01:13:47,706
to judge them against the other team.

1686
01:13:47,716 --> 01:13:51,966
So, so when we did the award ceremony,
like we had a whole separate category,

1687
01:13:52,296 --> 01:13:56,586
like we knowledge the people who, who
were not in either of those queues and

1688
01:13:56,586 --> 01:13:58,026
that's, that's what it's all about.

1689
01:13:58,026 --> 01:13:58,986
That's what remains about.

1690
01:14:00,036 --> 01:14:03,696
Acknowledging everybody saying,
Hey, these are the cool things.

1691
01:14:03,696 --> 01:14:06,036
Like, you know, that you
did these equal things.

1692
01:14:06,036 --> 01:14:06,426
I do.

1693
01:14:06,666 --> 01:14:08,136
They're not always equitable.

1694
01:14:08,136 --> 01:14:10,938
They're not always exactly, you
know quality you know, based.

1695
01:14:11,019 --> 01:14:14,662
But you know, some people work
better, under deadline but some people

1696
01:14:14,662 --> 01:14:16,252
don't work good hunter that line.

1697
01:14:16,372 --> 01:14:18,982
So that was only one aspect of family.

1698
01:14:19,012 --> 01:14:20,812
That was, that was, that
was the forward facing.

1699
01:14:20,812 --> 01:14:22,762
That was the, you know,
let's, let's promote.

1700
01:14:22,762 --> 01:14:23,842
And let's like, do the thing.

1701
01:14:24,262 --> 01:14:27,586
We also had the the free dreamers
is what I call them or the

1702
01:14:27,586 --> 01:14:28,936
lucid dreamers is what I call

1703
01:14:28,936 --> 01:14:29,086
them.

1704
01:14:29,406 --> 01:14:29,816
John: dreamers.

1705
01:14:29,816 --> 01:14:30,356
Yes.

1706
01:14:30,616 --> 01:14:30,946
Ben R: Yeah.

1707
01:14:31,006 --> 01:14:33,466
Which is, you know, just
do whatever you want.

1708
01:14:33,526 --> 01:14:35,716
Do it on your own time, do
it at your own schedule.

1709
01:14:35,896 --> 01:14:37,216
Nobody's going to be pressuring you.

1710
01:14:37,246 --> 01:14:41,236
Nobody's going to be giving you
a time or or anything take this

1711
01:14:41,236 --> 01:14:45,363
week for yourself to work on your
own, whatever you think is best.

1712
01:14:46,148 --> 01:14:49,788
And that kind of freedom, Dhaka
freedom is the thing that people

1713
01:14:49,788 --> 01:14:51,318
came back to me time and time again.

1714
01:14:51,318 --> 01:14:55,518
And I, I passed these, these things
along to other people because I was

1715
01:14:55,518 --> 01:14:59,388
the only one of the organizers I was,
I was the most front-facing one, but I

1716
01:14:59,388 --> 01:15:03,082
was, I was the only one of the people
like that was making all this happen.

1717
01:15:03,082 --> 01:15:06,785
Like it was, it took a lot of work
behind the scenes, like, you know, get

1718
01:15:06,785 --> 01:15:10,975
the leads on board to get the, the, the
licensing like You don't think about this.

1719
01:15:10,975 --> 01:15:13,825
Like, you know, if we're going to
around me making something at a, as an

1720
01:15:13,825 --> 01:15:16,855
official studio, we have to make sure
that every single thing is licensed.

1721
01:15:17,095 --> 01:15:17,515
Everything.

1722
01:15:17,545 --> 01:15:20,665
Several thing is if you're using a
piece of software, if you're using, if

1723
01:15:20,665 --> 01:15:24,415
you're using an asset, if you're using
a sound, everything has to be fully

1724
01:15:24,415 --> 01:15:26,215
licensed in order to be in compliance.

1725
01:15:26,215 --> 01:15:29,029
Because we we can't, we can't
make herself vulnerable like that.

1726
01:15:29,029 --> 01:15:30,409
We're, we're a big company.

1727
01:15:30,409 --> 01:15:33,949
Like we're doing, even if it's
never released to the public, even

1728
01:15:33,949 --> 01:15:37,189
if it's not for commercial release,
doing something like that, like it's

1729
01:15:37,189 --> 01:15:40,522
something again, it gets back to, you
don't think about the marketing costs.

1730
01:15:40,582 --> 01:15:43,582
You don't think about the licensing
of the software costs or the

1731
01:15:43,582 --> 01:15:44,872
licensing of the asset costs.

1732
01:15:45,069 --> 01:15:48,939
every single thing that was made in
dream week had to be homegrown, had to be

1733
01:15:49,314 --> 01:15:49,914
John: Okay.

1734
01:15:50,054 --> 01:15:50,594
Okay.

1735
01:15:50,649 --> 01:15:53,769
Ben R: not, you're not allowed
to use anything LA, unless It

1736
01:15:53,769 --> 01:15:57,939
is like MIT license or something
that's already for you license use.

1737
01:15:58,599 --> 01:16:02,574
that was that was the only like so stuff
on the unreal store is all fair game.

1738
01:16:03,489 --> 01:16:06,189
Because when you buy it,
you buy it in perpetuity.

1739
01:16:06,539 --> 01:16:07,139
John: Yes.

1740
01:16:07,239 --> 01:16:09,279
Ben R: part of organizing
dream week was making sure that

1741
01:16:09,279 --> 01:16:10,629
everybody was in compliance.

1742
01:16:11,442 --> 01:16:13,632
John: like, I'm just curious
about the rule set, right?

1743
01:16:13,632 --> 01:16:19,755
Like we got the timeframe is everybody
using like a same set of a consistent

1744
01:16:19,755 --> 01:16:22,035
engine as the consistent like ID or.

1745
01:16:22,532 --> 01:16:26,184
Ben R: I wanted to make it more open,
like where you could use, you know,

1746
01:16:26,874 --> 01:16:31,523
you use whatever, but due to compliance
we, we had to restrict it you know, to,

1747
01:16:31,553 --> 01:16:35,619
to unreal just because that was, only
one that we could guarantee compliance

1748
01:16:35,724 --> 01:16:36,024
John: Okay.

1749
01:16:36,024 --> 01:16:38,394
You guys had a, I don't
know what they call it.

1750
01:16:38,394 --> 01:16:39,414
A multi-user license

1751
01:16:39,414 --> 01:16:39,744
or some

1752
01:16:40,179 --> 01:16:40,589
Ben R: unity.

1753
01:16:40,599 --> 01:16:44,379
We, we got in touch with one of
their, like BizDev people, like we had

1754
01:16:44,649 --> 01:16:48,789
conditional licenses, but then they would,
they said after the event, like, they're

1755
01:16:48,789 --> 01:16:50,289
going to take back licenses and like,

1756
01:16:51,434 --> 01:16:52,514
John: per seat, right?

1757
01:16:52,994 --> 01:16:53,324
Ben R: Yeah.

1758
01:16:53,704 --> 01:16:53,944
Yeah.

1759
01:16:54,194 --> 01:16:57,704
So it was, it was, a whole
thing, but no, we looked at Good.

1760
01:16:57,704 --> 01:16:58,484
DOE in gen.

1761
01:16:58,484 --> 01:16:58,634
We

1762
01:16:58,694 --> 01:16:59,174
John: Yeah.

1763
01:16:59,204 --> 01:16:59,384
Good.

1764
01:16:59,384 --> 01:17:00,224
Those free

1765
01:17:00,374 --> 01:17:03,639
Ben R: looked at the, the, whatever
the successor Columbia yard is it's

1766
01:17:03,639 --> 01:17:03,879
called.

1767
01:17:03,879 --> 01:17:04,029
Like,

1768
01:17:04,159 --> 01:17:04,849
John: 3d E.

1769
01:17:05,889 --> 01:17:06,999
Ben R: we looked at all these things.

1770
01:17:07,285 --> 01:17:11,975
and, you know, I wanted to people to
look at other tool sets and look at

1771
01:17:11,975 --> 01:17:16,745
other pipelines because I think just
come off of using our own internal engine

1772
01:17:16,745 --> 01:17:18,282
for the last, you know, 30 years or

1773
01:17:18,282 --> 01:17:18,852
whatever it

1774
01:17:19,030 --> 01:17:19,270
John: Yeah.

1775
01:17:19,270 --> 01:17:21,933
It's so good to see how
the ways to do the thing.

1776
01:17:21,933 --> 01:17:22,233
Right.

1777
01:17:22,233 --> 01:17:23,193
And like, bring that back.

1778
01:17:24,148 --> 01:17:24,658
Ben R: It's good.

1779
01:17:24,658 --> 01:17:27,898
Just to look at other, other tool
sets and other ways of thinking

1780
01:17:27,898 --> 01:17:31,178
and like other design paradigms
and patterns and like everything.

1781
01:17:31,319 --> 01:17:33,862
I just learned recently
that unreal has utility.

1782
01:17:33,862 --> 01:17:34,942
blueprints, obesity.

1783
01:17:34,970 --> 01:17:35,780
John: Utility.

1784
01:17:35,930 --> 01:17:39,130
Ben R: Even build tools in the
unreal engine in blueprint, like

1785
01:17:39,130 --> 01:17:43,270
you can make, you can make unreal
blueprint tools that are like, you

1786
01:17:43,270 --> 01:17:45,470
know, windows that show up, like as

1787
01:17:45,940 --> 01:17:47,770
an editor window, then a real,

1788
01:17:47,900 --> 01:17:48,500
John: oh shit.

1789
01:17:48,500 --> 01:17:50,390
So like MF like windows.

1790
01:17:50,450 --> 01:17:50,840
Okay.

1791
01:17:50,870 --> 01:17:51,080
Okay.

1792
01:17:51,080 --> 01:17:52,010
I gotta look this up, man.

1793
01:17:52,010 --> 01:17:52,760
You teach him me

1794
01:17:52,920 --> 01:17:54,360
Ben R: it's still an engine

1795
01:17:55,520 --> 01:17:56,060
John: separately.

1796
01:17:56,970 --> 01:17:59,760
Ben R: or window out or an asset
browser window or something like that

1797
01:18:00,015 --> 01:18:00,195
John: you,

1798
01:18:00,195 --> 01:18:01,665
know, tools are my jam, bro.

1799
01:18:01,665 --> 01:18:03,045
So I got, I gotta look into this.

1800
01:18:03,045 --> 01:18:03,165
I'm

1801
01:18:03,165 --> 01:18:04,005
excited about that.

1802
01:18:04,440 --> 01:18:09,210
Ben R: Look, they used to call it blue
utility, I think was the old term,

1803
01:18:09,510 --> 01:18:11,490
but yeah, it's a utility blueprints.

1804
01:18:11,574 --> 01:18:12,984
John: That's native to the engine.

1805
01:18:12,984 --> 01:18:14,874
That's not like a plugin,
a third party plugin.

1806
01:18:15,159 --> 01:18:15,519
Ben R: Right.

1807
01:18:15,519 --> 01:18:20,589
as a 16 year old game, like ideologists,
like, you know, you have an idea, but

1808
01:18:20,589 --> 01:18:22,149
you don't know how to make games yet.

1809
01:18:22,419 --> 01:18:25,089
Why, why are we making it so hard them?

1810
01:18:25,599 --> 01:18:25,989
why is it.

1811
01:18:25,989 --> 01:18:28,749
so hard for, for a person
that just has a game idea?

1812
01:18:29,109 --> 01:18:33,519
Like, I I've been pitched so many game
ideas, but by people outside the game

1813
01:18:33,519 --> 01:18:36,399
industry, when I tell them what we game
designer, like they come to me and they

1814
01:18:36,399 --> 01:18:37,779
say, oh, I have the signing for game.

1815
01:18:37,779 --> 01:18:38,439
Why don't we do this?

1816
01:18:38,439 --> 01:18:39,099
And this and this.

1817
01:18:39,290 --> 01:18:41,940
and I say to them the same thing
I would say to any of my students,

1818
01:18:41,940 --> 01:18:45,180
same thing I'd say to anybody
else's game jam that I'm evaluating.

1819
01:18:45,990 --> 01:18:46,710
What is the goal?

1820
01:18:47,400 --> 01:18:51,277
What, what, how do you win or
lose and what hurdles are you

1821
01:18:51,487 --> 01:18:52,837
presenting the player along the way

1822
01:18:53,536 --> 01:18:54,076
John: boom.

1823
01:18:54,106 --> 01:18:55,366
Bring it all full circle.

1824
01:18:55,576 --> 01:18:56,356
I'm a friend.

1825
01:18:56,746 --> 01:18:59,476
We are going to enter the final round.

1826
01:18:59,506 --> 01:19:00,496
Are you ready?

1827
01:19:00,771 --> 01:19:01,401
Ben R: fun.

1828
01:19:04,516 --> 01:19:04,786
John: Fight?

1829
01:19:04,786 --> 01:19:05,026
No.

1830
01:19:12,696 --> 01:19:13,566
I forgot, man.

1831
01:19:13,566 --> 01:19:14,946
You got a good voice, man.

1832
01:19:14,976 --> 01:19:15,906
We haven't done like,

1833
01:19:16,351 --> 01:19:17,161
Ben R: I played in a band in

1834
01:19:17,171 --> 01:19:19,021
San Francisco, max rats,

1835
01:19:19,356 --> 01:19:20,466
John: God damn.

1836
01:19:20,646 --> 01:19:21,336
I love it.

1837
01:19:21,546 --> 01:19:21,996
All right.

1838
01:19:22,056 --> 01:19:23,706
What's the last game you finished?

1839
01:19:25,081 --> 01:19:27,361
Ben R: shit finish like, okay.

1840
01:19:27,421 --> 01:19:28,801
Are you talking about completionist?

1841
01:19:28,926 --> 01:19:29,066
John: the

1842
01:19:30,132 --> 01:19:31,372
Ben R: half-life Alex was

1843
01:19:31,392 --> 01:19:33,682
last one I can say to the credits.

1844
01:19:33,897 --> 01:19:36,593
John: Did you think that was a
great like test of the medium?

1845
01:19:36,748 --> 01:19:37,848
Ben R: is half-life three.

1846
01:19:38,178 --> 01:19:38,548
It is.

1847
01:19:38,578 --> 01:19:39,208
It really is.

1848
01:19:39,208 --> 01:19:40,768
It's the next evolution of half-life.

1849
01:19:40,798 --> 01:19:44,398
That is the best, I mean, like I play a
lot of games for competitive analysis and

1850
01:19:44,398 --> 01:19:46,859
I watch a lot of pro players play games.

1851
01:19:46,859 --> 01:19:48,282
I love games done quick.

1852
01:19:48,314 --> 01:19:52,454
I love seeing how the way people have to
ways around games or, or use glitches,

1853
01:19:52,454 --> 01:19:55,917
like in order to get past lake shore in
areas it reminds me of the importance of

1854
01:19:55,917 --> 01:20:01,569
QA and, and how much I loved being in QA
and now valuable or QA testers are like

1855
01:20:02,109 --> 01:20:04,929
with a work from home environment, like
people are trying to outsource that stuff.

1856
01:20:04,929 --> 01:20:07,249
And like, you have to
have embedded QA, you

1857
01:20:07,329 --> 01:20:07,839
John: Yes.

1858
01:20:07,909 --> 01:20:10,669
Ben R: testers that are in
part of your pod that like,

1859
01:20:10,669 --> 01:20:12,289
understand what the goals are

1860
01:20:12,613 --> 01:20:13,504
John: 100%

1861
01:20:13,745 --> 01:20:17,096
Ben R: you have to make a AAA game
dev potty, you got to have a designer,

1862
01:20:17,576 --> 01:20:19,076
have a producer, you got to have QA.

1863
01:20:19,140 --> 01:20:20,673
those are the three basic requirements.

1864
01:20:20,673 --> 01:20:22,233
Like engineer would be great.

1865
01:20:22,338 --> 01:20:23,808
John: artists would be great.

1866
01:20:24,123 --> 01:20:24,963
Ben R: artists will be great.

1867
01:20:24,993 --> 01:20:26,023
Sometimes not always built.

1868
01:20:26,043 --> 01:20:27,693
Oh, those are shared resources.

1869
01:20:27,738 --> 01:20:28,288
John: Yeah.

1870
01:20:28,468 --> 01:20:28,738
Yeah.

1871
01:20:28,768 --> 01:20:30,418
They're always shared audio person.

1872
01:20:30,418 --> 01:20:30,778
Yeah.

1873
01:20:31,208 --> 01:20:32,648
What's the last book you read?

1874
01:20:32,757 --> 01:20:33,807
Or listen to

1875
01:20:35,017 --> 01:20:37,403
Ben R: oh I, I was just
reading ready player two.

1876
01:20:37,422 --> 01:20:42,281
I really loved the only decline
is I, I both read and listen to

1877
01:20:42,281 --> 01:20:42,971
audio book.

1878
01:20:43,047 --> 01:20:44,367
It's narrated by Wil Wheaton.

1879
01:20:44,434 --> 01:20:48,329
I don't know if he's still doing tabletop
gaming, but he used to do a great thing

1880
01:20:48,343 --> 01:20:48,893
John: on YouTube.

1881
01:20:49,011 --> 01:20:52,251
Ben R: Where you, you would show different
tabletop games, which like, again,

1882
01:20:52,431 --> 01:20:53,651
it's like one of these things where.

1883
01:20:54,446 --> 01:20:57,967
I don't always have the the full amount
of time to like sit down and play game.

1884
01:20:57,967 --> 01:21:00,667
But if I can watch a game or van
watch somebody break down the rules

1885
01:21:00,877 --> 01:21:03,937
and they do a really good job of
making it entertaining and keeping

1886
01:21:03,937 --> 01:21:07,276
the, keeping the rule set relevant
and like you know like making, but

1887
01:21:07,296 --> 01:21:08,976
understanding the context of the game.

1888
01:21:09,066 --> 01:21:10,656
Like they get into the character.

1889
01:21:10,656 --> 01:21:15,123
It's like, watching your favorite
star Trek actors embody the roles

1890
01:21:15,123 --> 01:21:16,743
of, the characters in the board game.

1891
01:21:16,743 --> 01:21:16,953
So

1892
01:21:17,743 --> 01:21:18,193
John: That's cool.

1893
01:21:18,193 --> 01:21:19,873
The little role playing aspect of it.

1894
01:21:19,873 --> 01:21:20,203
Yeah.

1895
01:21:20,203 --> 01:21:20,623
I love it.

1896
01:21:21,403 --> 01:21:21,793
Okay.

1897
01:21:21,883 --> 01:21:25,603
So you've done a lot, Ben,
you know, like you said

1898
01:21:25,709 --> 01:21:26,959
Ben R: I wouldn't say
I've done a lot of sanity.

1899
01:21:26,959 --> 01:21:27,689
I've done a little,

1900
01:21:27,799 --> 01:21:28,069
John: okay.

1901
01:21:28,069 --> 01:21:28,489
You've done

1902
01:21:28,969 --> 01:21:29,999
Ben R: a little bit of everything,

1903
01:21:30,169 --> 01:21:31,159
John: a little bit of everything, right?

1904
01:21:31,159 --> 01:21:35,269
Like you've worked on one of, almost
every type of game in the genre,

1905
01:21:35,269 --> 01:21:37,279
across platform, across types.

1906
01:21:37,669 --> 01:21:39,199
You've been in robotics.

1907
01:21:39,199 --> 01:21:42,349
You entrepreneurs some shit
you've been in academia.

1908
01:21:42,357 --> 01:21:44,052
All of, all of those, right.

1909
01:21:44,052 --> 01:21:47,172
If you had to pick one thing,
what are you most proud of?

1910
01:21:48,532 --> 01:21:49,942
Ben R: I'm most proud of being a student.

1911
01:21:50,152 --> 01:21:52,792
I'm an eternal student and everybody
should be an eternal student.

1912
01:21:53,002 --> 01:21:54,112
I'm learning every day.

1913
01:21:54,172 --> 01:21:57,352
Every, every single thing
that I've done is just another

1914
01:21:57,352 --> 01:21:58,882
way for me to gain knowledge.

1915
01:21:59,182 --> 01:22:04,732
Like, until the day I die until,
you know, I have my last breath,

1916
01:22:04,732 --> 01:22:07,702
like I'm, I'm going to be an eternal
student and everybody should strive

1917
01:22:07,702 --> 01:22:09,799
to be so there is no mastery.

1918
01:22:09,829 --> 01:22:12,289
Like there is no completionist
score in the game of life.

1919
01:22:12,483 --> 01:22:14,493
the more, you know, the more
you realize you don't know

1920
01:22:14,493 --> 01:22:16,083
is a common attic added them.

1921
01:22:16,083 --> 01:22:19,727
But you know, the only way you
lose bringing it full circle,

1922
01:22:20,057 --> 01:22:22,427
the win loss condition, the
only way you lose the game of?

1923
01:22:22,427 --> 01:22:23,087
life is when you start.

1924
01:22:23,714 --> 01:22:24,284
John: I'm with you.

1925
01:22:24,314 --> 01:22:24,974
I agree.

1926
01:22:25,214 --> 01:22:27,854
The day you stop learning
is the day you die, man.

1927
01:22:27,854 --> 01:22:31,214
The day your mind stops being
important to stops having inputs.

1928
01:22:31,214 --> 01:22:31,454
Right?

1929
01:22:31,454 --> 01:22:32,654
So it's not going to give you any outputs.

1930
01:22:32,654 --> 01:22:33,164
I like that.

1931
01:22:33,164 --> 01:22:33,674
I'm with you.

1932
01:22:34,244 --> 01:22:39,614
If you can go back and talk to 18 year
old Ben written, what would you tell him?

1933
01:22:40,704 --> 01:22:41,214
Ben R: shit.

1934
01:22:41,339 --> 01:22:43,439
was making great stock
investments at the time.

1935
01:22:43,439 --> 01:22:45,519
I would've said, keep it,
keep your stock investments.

1936
01:22:45,562 --> 01:22:48,716
But if I had to give him like a nugget of
wisdom for how to give him the nugget I

1937
01:22:48,716 --> 01:22:51,086
would say, well, listen more talk less.

1938
01:22:51,946 --> 01:22:53,386
John: Oh, okay.

1939
01:22:53,721 --> 01:22:54,951
The two ears, one mouth.

1940
01:22:55,054 --> 01:22:56,944
Ben R: Yeah, one mine years.

1941
01:22:57,069 --> 01:22:57,549
John: Okay.

1942
01:22:57,549 --> 01:22:58,029
Okay.

1943
01:22:58,059 --> 01:22:58,359
Dope.

1944
01:22:58,389 --> 01:22:59,019
I liked that one.

1945
01:22:59,199 --> 01:22:59,859
All right, brother.

1946
01:22:59,982 --> 01:23:01,722
Where can people reach out?

1947
01:23:01,752 --> 01:23:03,942
Connect a few, see what
you guys are working on.

1948
01:23:03,942 --> 01:23:05,082
Are you guys hiring

1949
01:23:05,397 --> 01:23:07,017
Ben R: We absolutely
are hiring it to gain.

1950
01:23:07,041 --> 01:23:11,019
We, we have a job board they're
listed you know, we, we have a

1951
01:23:11,019 --> 01:23:12,429
couple of projects in the works.

1952
01:23:12,452 --> 01:23:14,450
You know if you reach out to
our recruiters, they can tell

1953
01:23:14,450 --> 01:23:17,520
you a little bit more about what
opportunities are available.

1954
01:23:17,520 --> 01:23:20,520
you can also look me
up on Ben written.com.

1955
01:23:20,760 --> 01:23:22,050
You'll look me up on my website.

1956
01:23:22,143 --> 01:23:24,603
I do want to say a couple of things.

1957
01:23:24,603 --> 01:23:29,273
So, I'm trying to think about like what
the future of not just Yes, but the

1958
01:23:29,273 --> 01:23:30,983
future of game development and like,

1959
01:23:31,128 --> 01:23:31,848
John: interactive?

1960
01:23:32,303 --> 01:23:35,845
Ben R: make it better for developers
to make games as opposed to just

1961
01:23:35,845 --> 01:23:39,475
like, that's part of what my learnings
were from dream week was like, I was

1962
01:23:39,675 --> 01:23:44,305
observing, I was watching, know, how do
we make the future of gaming together

1963
01:23:44,545 --> 01:23:48,175
in collaboration and how do we not
reinvent the exploding red barrel?

1964
01:23:48,555 --> 01:23:49,725
John: Amen to that, bro.

1965
01:23:49,755 --> 01:23:50,355
Amen to that.

1966
01:23:50,355 --> 01:23:54,945
I'm with that, I'm on the eternal search
for like optimizing game engines and

1967
01:23:54,945 --> 01:23:58,515
teaching people to use these things
and not have to, what do we say?

1968
01:23:58,515 --> 01:24:02,535
We say like you spend 60, 70% of the
time just making something work and you

1969
01:24:02,535 --> 01:24:04,455
only have like 30, 40% to make it fun.

1970
01:24:04,455 --> 01:24:04,905
You know what I'm saying?

1971
01:24:04,915 --> 01:24:05,835
Want to flip that shit?

1972
01:24:06,103 --> 01:24:09,122
Ben R: Also another thing that I, I
mean, I kinda knew this was like as

1973
01:24:09,122 --> 01:24:12,782
18 old Ben, but like somebody that
same to myself, again, like just to

1974
01:24:12,782 --> 01:24:14,672
reiterate was write everything down.

1975
01:24:15,032 --> 01:24:20,252
If you are, if you a new person, can't,
recount the number of journals like that.

1976
01:24:20,252 --> 01:24:23,732
I have, I found recently that of like,
you know, especially during COVID, when

1977
01:24:23,732 --> 01:24:27,212
you start to pull out all the boxes
and the start to open up all the books,

1978
01:24:27,962 --> 01:24:29,732
damn, that was a great idea that I wrote.

1979
01:24:30,302 --> 01:24:33,511
Like 18 years ago, like
write everything down.

1980
01:24:34,081 --> 01:24:37,411
even if it's all white board and even
if it's temporary like that, the act of

1981
01:24:37,681 --> 01:24:37,861
John: Okay.

1982
01:24:37,861 --> 01:24:40,481
Ben R: they say that it's an education
when you're learning about education.

1983
01:24:40,481 --> 01:24:44,612
you know, so much from listening, you
learn so much from speaking, learn so

1984
01:24:44,612 --> 01:24:49,404
much from writing, going the most from
teaching, like the, the, just the act of,

1985
01:24:49,644 --> 01:24:53,825
of taking it from your conscious mind and,
and like having to you know, alliterate

1986
01:24:53,866 --> 01:24:58,122
you know, trying to write that down, like
if you're trying to, transcribe like your

1987
01:24:58,122 --> 01:25:01,902
thoughts, it is, it is important process.

1988
01:25:02,096 --> 01:25:05,159
again, it gets, back to the quantum
computing those neural pathways.

1989
01:25:05,909 --> 01:25:08,759
John: definitely I plus a
thousand that I liked that too.

1990
01:25:08,759 --> 01:25:08,999
Right?

1991
01:25:08,999 --> 01:25:13,169
Like we can watch things to the end
of time we can listen to things,

1992
01:25:13,169 --> 01:25:17,069
but it isn't until we go through the
active step of writing it down, that

1993
01:25:17,069 --> 01:25:18,599
it actually starts to kind of sink in.

1994
01:25:19,389 --> 01:25:20,499
Ben R: What's the difference
between books and.

1995
01:25:21,576 --> 01:25:22,526
John: Exactly right.

1996
01:25:22,686 --> 01:25:24,966
Passive versus a interactive right.

1997
01:25:25,481 --> 01:25:26,051
Ben R: I have passive

1998
01:25:26,076 --> 01:25:27,306
John: Act passive versus active.

1999
01:25:28,301 --> 01:25:29,531
Ben R: through the act of writing it down.

2000
01:25:29,531 --> 01:25:30,521
You are being active.

2001
01:25:30,521 --> 01:25:31,721
You're no longer passive.

2002
01:25:32,566 --> 01:25:33,016
John: I love it.

2003
01:25:34,036 --> 01:25:36,586
Who do you nominate?

2004
01:25:36,616 --> 01:25:39,646
We will, right now we're on the
second season of the podcast, right?

2005
01:25:39,646 --> 01:25:42,384
So we already know the criteria.

2006
01:25:43,880 --> 01:25:46,700
Ben R: I'm telling you, Kim Hudson,
can I send you your next get.

2007
01:25:46,915 --> 01:25:50,665
John: I nominate kid Hudson to fall
out of the play area behind you.

2008
01:25:50,665 --> 01:25:53,305
Ben, I'm going to make that shit happen.

2009
01:25:53,365 --> 01:25:56,545
And even if God, if I, even if I
got a name drop, you was like, yo

2010
01:25:56,545 --> 01:25:58,585
bro, Ben red wants to hear you.

2011
01:25:58,585 --> 01:25:59,305
Come on the show.

2012
01:25:59,305 --> 01:26:00,365
You can't say no to him.

2013
01:26:00,368 --> 01:26:01,748
I'm going to make that
happen for you, bro.

2014
01:26:01,958 --> 01:26:06,188
Do you have any last words for the
people out there before we wrap up?

2015
01:26:06,611 --> 01:26:07,691
Ben R: Don't stop dreaming.

2016
01:26:07,759 --> 01:26:12,797
You know you may think that that
you're just a pawn in the game of life.

2017
01:26:13,217 --> 01:26:16,937
might think that you're being
played by other players take back

2018
01:26:16,937 --> 01:26:22,217
that agency, remember that you are
your own master of your own reality

2019
01:26:22,427 --> 01:26:24,107
and that this is just a dream.

2020
01:26:24,617 --> 01:26:26,807
We're just the imaginations of ourselves.

2021
01:26:26,807 --> 01:26:30,377
And, you know, your perception is reality.

2022
01:26:30,758 --> 01:26:31,898
John: Going back to that dream thing.

2023
01:26:31,898 --> 01:26:36,848
One last thing before we wrap it
up, how much work or time of effort

2024
01:26:36,848 --> 01:26:38,678
did it take to make dream week?

2025
01:26:39,728 --> 01:26:45,022
Ben R: Months months, months of red tape
paperwork getting across borders, state

2026
01:26:45,022 --> 01:26:49,901
workers, like was, it was not an easy
process, but I had a great, great, great

2027
01:26:49,931 --> 01:26:51,731
group of people helping me along the way.

2028
01:26:51,941 --> 01:26:53,913
It takes a village make a game.

2029
01:26:53,941 --> 01:26:55,713
there is no grandma's boy,

2030
01:26:56,223 --> 01:26:56,373
you

2031
01:26:56,553 --> 01:26:57,633
John: Oh, God,

2032
01:26:57,741 --> 01:26:59,151
Ben R: you don't make a game in isolation.

2033
01:26:59,151 --> 01:26:59,511
You don't,

2034
01:26:59,781 --> 01:27:00,711
John: the console.

2035
01:27:00,721 --> 01:27:04,461
He just took the Xbox home
and he became the controller.

2036
01:27:04,951 --> 01:27:07,638
Ben R: a guy who made a
a Titanic mod, the mafia.

2037
01:27:08,563 --> 01:27:09,853
Original mafia, mafia,

2038
01:27:10,178 --> 01:27:10,598
John: Yeah.

2039
01:27:10,993 --> 01:27:13,433
Ben R: 20 years to make it, if you
want to get something to market,

2040
01:27:13,583 --> 01:27:16,825
like if you wanted to be in her
lifetime, you gotta work with people.

2041
01:27:16,859 --> 01:27:19,679
Be willing to work with people, be
willing to make concessions reach

2042
01:27:19,679 --> 01:27:22,829
across the aisle, you know, shake
hands with people and, you know

2043
01:27:25,493 --> 01:27:26,723
Speaking of working with people.

2044
01:27:26,723 --> 01:27:31,669
We do want to mention that we have some
jobs open, here@twokyoucangototwok.com

2045
01:27:31,699 --> 01:27:32,809
and there's a job section.

2046
01:27:33,109 --> 01:27:35,209
You can also go to the greenhouse website.

2047
01:27:35,404 --> 01:27:41,934
that website is going to be
boards.greenhouse.io/two K.

2048
01:27:42,193 --> 01:27:42,583
John: I love it.

2049
01:27:42,583 --> 01:27:43,273
Yo, aye.

2050
01:27:43,333 --> 01:27:44,623
We outta here.

2051
01:27:45,615 --> 01:27:48,315
In this industry, I'm lucky
to bump into people who offer

2052
01:27:48,315 --> 01:27:50,648
such an interesting on the way.

2053
01:27:50,648 --> 01:27:54,787
To look at life and thinkers that
I can have a profound conversation

2054
01:27:54,787 --> 01:27:59,737
with in whatever direction, without
any kind of guidance or notes.

2055
01:28:00,457 --> 01:28:05,677
I mean, Ben is a life, a self-proclaimed
lifelong student who admits to

2056
01:28:05,677 --> 01:28:08,347
not being able to sleep because
he's always working on something.

2057
01:28:09,397 --> 01:28:12,067
This interview felt different to
me compared to my other episodes.

2058
01:28:12,127 --> 01:28:16,027
It felt like we were simply on a wave,
just discussing the arts of games.

2059
01:28:16,567 --> 01:28:18,367
And if it didn't sink in, remember.

2060
01:28:18,607 --> 01:28:21,877
The first thing about making
a game is defining the goal.

2061
01:28:21,877 --> 01:28:23,017
What's the wind condition.

2062
01:28:23,017 --> 01:28:24,127
What's the loss condition.

2063
01:28:24,459 --> 01:28:27,909
I know this is a wide spectrum and
interactive entertainment, and you could

2064
01:28:27,909 --> 01:28:33,129
definitely get into a debate on what
it means to be a game and not having to

2065
01:28:33,129 --> 01:28:36,009
have a specific win or loss condition.

2066
01:28:37,239 --> 01:28:41,079
I remember in my days in school was
definitely one of the early bits were

2067
01:28:41,079 --> 01:28:42,639
taught when breaking down game theory.

2068
01:28:43,629 --> 01:28:46,989
I can walk away with a bit more pride
in what I do up until this conversation.

2069
01:28:46,989 --> 01:28:51,219
I would not have looked at somebody
designing chess to be an artist.

2070
01:28:51,249 --> 01:28:51,909
And now.

2071
01:28:52,749 --> 01:28:58,299
I agree if you can break down a rule set
that eloquently, that everything kind of.

2072
01:28:59,109 --> 01:29:02,979
Saul, you know, balances
out and leads to a win.

2073
01:29:03,170 --> 01:29:05,210
Uh, loss or a stalemate.

2074
01:29:05,290 --> 01:29:06,340
That that is an art.

2075
01:29:06,427 --> 01:29:07,927
And not everyone can do it.

2076
01:29:08,225 --> 01:29:11,345
It makes me think about the time I
went through rules of the game at full.

2077
01:29:11,345 --> 01:29:15,185
So my class with Dave, Arneson the
creator of Dungeons and dragons.

2078
01:29:15,185 --> 01:29:15,275
And.

2079
01:29:15,815 --> 01:29:17,465
I'll be honest for me.

2080
01:29:17,585 --> 01:29:19,025
I didn't appreciate that time.

2081
01:29:19,085 --> 01:29:22,895
I couldn't tell you much about that
class other than getting to know

2082
01:29:23,195 --> 01:29:25,805
about the awesome board game in Katon.

2083
01:29:25,925 --> 01:29:26,105
Right?

2084
01:29:26,105 --> 01:29:27,875
That was my biggest
takeaway from that class.

2085
01:29:28,230 --> 01:29:31,430
And if I could go retake
that with him, I would.

2086
01:29:31,549 --> 01:29:34,789
But I'll never have that
opportunity again, because Dave

2087
01:29:34,789 --> 01:29:37,399
has moved on to that next life RPG.

2088
01:29:37,916 --> 01:29:41,756
So I really take advantage of being able
to talk to people like Ben or Jamison

2089
01:29:41,756 --> 01:29:46,826
to Raul who unlike me cherish that class
and soaked it up and really connected

2090
01:29:46,826 --> 01:29:48,926
with one of the OGs in this game space.

2091
01:29:48,956 --> 01:29:48,966
Uh,

2092
01:29:49,692 --> 01:29:54,762
one of the greatest things I took
away from Amazon was our dedicated.

2093
01:29:54,940 --> 01:29:59,190
Leadership principle to learn and
be curious, which manifested itself.

2094
01:29:59,303 --> 01:30:01,643
As actual days in the scheduling.

2095
01:30:01,643 --> 01:30:01,913
Right?

2096
01:30:01,913 --> 01:30:04,103
I think it was like 20% of our schedule.

2097
01:30:04,103 --> 01:30:06,203
I would be learning and be curious days.

2098
01:30:06,628 --> 01:30:12,790
And we were empowered to go off
and pick up a new technology, read

2099
01:30:12,790 --> 01:30:16,690
something, anything that would
get the creative juices flowing.

2100
01:30:16,750 --> 01:30:17,620
That we could.

2101
01:30:18,040 --> 01:30:22,360
Bring back as a skill to empower
the business or what have you.

2102
01:30:22,870 --> 01:30:23,260
And.

2103
01:30:23,920 --> 01:30:26,110
Then even at.

2104
01:30:26,740 --> 01:30:29,890
EA we had something like this,
I forget what they were called.

2105
01:30:30,130 --> 01:30:32,530
And it was something that was easy
to kind of be like, oh yeah, we'll

2106
01:30:32,530 --> 01:30:35,440
push this off until planning or
push it off to the next milestone.

2107
01:30:35,440 --> 01:30:37,390
So you gotta be careful and
make sure that it stays.

2108
01:30:37,690 --> 01:30:41,620
Plan, but having it as part of the
culture was something that I'll never

2109
01:30:41,620 --> 01:30:45,580
forget because normally up until then,
everything I had done at a game studio was

2110
01:30:45,610 --> 01:30:47,830
just, feverously behind the pursuit of.

2111
01:30:47,830 --> 01:30:51,220
Getting whatever project shipped
or completed or hitting the next

2112
01:30:51,220 --> 01:30:54,670
milestone to get the next green
light meeting or something like that.

2113
01:30:55,420 --> 01:30:58,150
And at epic, I'm still trying
to figure it out, right?

2114
01:30:58,150 --> 01:31:04,960
Like, uh, ultimately it's very easy
to take advantage of the limitless

2115
01:31:04,960 --> 01:31:08,290
amount of opportunity of resources
we have available and go propose

2116
01:31:08,290 --> 01:31:09,760
something and then pursue it.

2117
01:31:10,180 --> 01:31:13,045
But I'm still trying to
learn the tact and strategy.

2118
01:31:13,045 --> 01:31:13,285
Right.

2119
01:31:13,285 --> 01:31:15,813
And still trying to
deliver my first big win.

2120
01:31:15,835 --> 01:31:17,905
As part of the team and prove myself.

2121
01:31:18,240 --> 01:31:22,710
For Ben to come into a company
where it's not the culture.

2122
01:31:22,710 --> 01:31:27,750
And really propose that and spin it
up grassroots with a group of people

2123
01:31:27,750 --> 01:31:31,980
and invest the months and months
and months into making the time and

2124
01:31:31,980 --> 01:31:36,478
finding the technology and clearing
all the assets and defining a rule set.

2125
01:31:36,505 --> 01:31:43,101
And making it as inclusive to all the
types of workers and people that you have.

2126
01:31:43,521 --> 01:31:44,721
It's just fantastic.

2127
01:31:45,021 --> 01:31:46,701
And it's a huge feat.

2128
01:31:46,731 --> 01:31:50,283
It is no small feat I think that was
my favorite part of the interview was

2129
01:31:50,313 --> 01:31:54,691
hearing about what dream week is, how it
came to be and what people got out of it.

2130
01:31:54,906 --> 01:31:58,146
I would love to connect with more
people who went through dream week.

2131
01:31:58,146 --> 01:31:59,856
If you were there, hit me up.

2132
01:31:59,886 --> 01:32:01,086
I'd welcome your story.

2133
01:32:02,104 --> 01:32:05,164
On episode 30, two of out to play
every, we sit down with Zach buck,

2134
01:32:05,194 --> 01:32:07,204
a designer at the wandering band.

2135
01:32:07,688 --> 01:32:10,748
I got to know about him as
a result of reading, Jason

2136
01:32:10,748 --> 01:32:12,458
Schrader's press reset book.

2137
01:32:12,488 --> 01:32:15,368
When I was working at EA at a time, he.

2138
01:32:15,452 --> 01:32:19,441
Had this kind of dream run through
the company where he got into QA and

2139
01:32:19,471 --> 01:32:23,101
worked his way up the ranks to senior
producer, to do all types of things at

2140
01:32:23,101 --> 01:32:25,381
EA and work on some amazing franchises.

2141
01:32:25,616 --> 01:32:30,116
You won't want to miss that story
that debuts on Monday, May 9th.

2142
01:32:30,316 --> 01:32:33,286
make sure to follow us so that you
don't miss out on that episode.

2143
01:32:33,489 --> 01:32:34,719
Thank you for listening, Deb.

2144
01:32:34,929 --> 01:32:38,859
If you found this episode informative,
I ask that you pay a link forward to

2145
01:32:38,859 --> 01:32:40,929
a developer to help grow our listener.

2146
01:32:41,689 --> 01:32:44,869
If you're a game developer with a
story you think could help a fellow dev

2147
01:32:44,899 --> 01:32:49,939
out, please go to out of play area.com
and click on the Calendly link at

2148
01:32:49,939 --> 01:32:53,315
the top to meet up, please make sure
you get approval from your manager

2149
01:32:53,315 --> 01:32:55,865
or studios, PR HR team beforehand.

2150
01:32:56,202 --> 01:33:00,732
Out of play area, the game developers,
podcasts releases, new episodes every

2151
01:33:00,732 --> 01:33:04,902
other Monday on all the major players,
including Spotify, apple, and Google.

2152
01:33:05,202 --> 01:33:08,762
Please make sure to follow us, to see
what developer falls out of the play area.

2153
01:33:08,812 --> 01:33:09,432
Next time.

2154
01:33:09,912 --> 01:33:13,932
I'm your host John Diaz until
next time devs stay strong.

2155
01:33:13,962 --> 01:33:14,742
Stay true.

2156
01:33:14,862 --> 01:33:16,092
Stay dangerous

